Indianexpress.com : comments : Advani wants ATS out, Rajnath warns of civil war danger

Advani wants ATS out, Rajnath warns of civil war danger

New Delhi/Lucknow, November 19:: The BJP top brass went all out to target the Congress-led UPA government over the handling of the Malegaon blast probe. While L K Advani accused the Maharashtra Anti-Terrorism Squad (ATS) of “acting in a politically motivated and unprofessional manner” and meting out “barbaric treatment” to bla ....Read more

Comments

Post comment

99 Comments |

Shree Rajnath Bhagwan uvachaBy: Jayadevan | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 13:35:50 PM Reply | Forward Rajnathji, staying in glass houses and throwing stones? In whose time were terrorists escorted to freedom by a cabinet minister? Who figured in the havala scandal and narrowly escaped only because the Court could not accept the Jain dairies as hard evidence? ( The Jains should have taken stamped receipts?) I faintly remember the names of some terrorists and your illustrious leader.. but of course, Advaniji is an honourable man. Remember any Muslim extremism in India before you people decided to capture votes using the Ram Janma Bhumi and brought down a dilapidated mosque? If you feel the Muslims reacted too violently to an action by Hindus, what about the communal rioting in 1990 when the police and the VHP clashed at the same site? Were the cops Muslims? Mulayam Singh a Muslim? I had no interest in the Babri Masjid.. I would have preferred a Sulabh Shauchalaya in its place. But you people have made God another stock on the Sensex. Shall we start on Mathura now? Guaranteed dividends!

disband ats etcBy: mohan | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 21:33:23 PM Reply | Forward my my. what a dispassionate and and shrewd analyst you are jayadevan? o, so where were you when the so called secular and muslim clergy browbeat a country's elected government to deny a poor woman's right to get maintainence?and where were you when the so called jihadis blasted away in as many as 6to 8 places ? and surely you were on some other planet when the kasmiri pandits were made refugees in their own land.! as for you preference for a sauchalaya in the place of babri masjid which anyway housed a temple as well be glad you belong to the hindu religion because if you were a muslim there would have been a baying for your head!and by way of closing why were the minority so excercised when by your own standards the mosque was a dialapedited one?.and even if it were so is exteremism the answer?. in that case when the (kasmiri problem)came up hindus should have long chosen the extremist path which they didnt.

Advaniji, Rajnath Singh By: maccikhan | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 13:26:05 PM Reply | Forward Perhaps this is the real hidden agenda of BJP, or let us put it this way. If BJP wins the next national election, this whole investigation will become trash-all those who are so to say involved and found guilty will be set free and paraded in the streets as heros by the BJP/VHP/BD. If they do not win the elections they would rather avenge this defeat by Civil war. I either case the nation will see the true colour. It is surprising why BJP who never wanted to comment all these days on Sadhvi and the accompalice suddenly signalling of civil war and threat to Hiduism. This is totally a hallow and mishcivous claim. How can anybody immagin a threat to Hindu religion, which is among one of the oldest religion with millioins and millions of followers spread all over the world. If thier is any threat to Hinduism,it is not from Muslims but certainly from these politicians who are using Hinduism just to divide people. It is these politicians who should be tought the basics of Nationalism

OutregiousBy: Raje | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 13:17:06 PM Reply | Forward What ever I am stating is unfortunate but true. MN Ray, the DGP of Maharastra, was appointed so over the head of other by CM Deshmukh. Maharastra govt has lost the case in CAT over Ray. Ray wants to carry on as DGP by hook and crook so does the govt. He has found the best opportunity in Sadhvi and Purohit. So far Amy and Police IAS officers are concerned, they are at virtual war on the issue of the Status of Lt gen and DGP the issue being looked into by a GoM. This is a political and election time. All the four factors are responsible for the Super plot and Coup masterminded by Bombay ATS. Appease Muslims, Ray to continue as DGP, Defame Army so their case before the Govt for equity of status is weakened. That is why Sadhvi, Lt Col, Hindutwa and Malegaon have been placed together. This is simply putting personal interests by IPS and Politicians above the national interests. This is most unfortunate...but true.

Respect of Indian LawBy: ramesh kumar | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 13:14:37 PM Reply | Forward Saeed Ahmed, do you have respect to India law? Only when it suits your requirement you choose to respect Indian Law, when it does not suit to your requirement, you demand for Sariat law. What a double standard? Do you agree? The moment you hear about 'hindu', you bring all the hatred in the world!

stop crying!!!!!By: Saccha Gujarati | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 16:51:25 PM Reply | Forward Yes, When you know ATS will crackdown the case, you want to replace officers. Please suggest to put gujurat investigation team and Mr. Nanavati as head of ATS, will it be fine. ATS is not run by Minority commission. My friend be patience let the court decide. Jai Hind

hindu terrorismBy: N.C.RAVINDRAKUMAR | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 13:06:20 PM Reply | Forward The extent of hype that is being given to project the so called "HINDU TERRORISM" IS DEPLORABLE. I STRONGLY SUSPECT THAT CONGRESS AND THE OTHER SO CALLED SECULAR PARTIES, WITH THE HELP OF MEDIA, AND OFFICIAL MACHINERY WANT TO TWIST THE TRUTH THAT IT IS HINDU ORGANISATIONS THAT ARE ENGAGED IN TERRORISM. THIS WILL ONLY UNIFY THE FRAGMENTED HINDU SOCIETY AND THE RESULT WOULD BE DISASTEROUS TO CONGRESS AND THE SO CALLED SECULAR PARTIES.

civil warBy: Tennyson Rodrigues | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 13:05:45 PM Reply | Forward Mr. Advani pls not to drag the our loved country into civil war, for ur selfish moto. Accept the fact and try to correct ur slef. U have alrady seen what happen when 1947. Thats why ur here today.Again u want to go to Pakistan!!!!

ReplyBy: Nitin | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 15:17:05 PM Reply | Forward Mr Tennyson, why are so worried. your name says you are european. you guys have created all the problems and now saying you don;t want another division.

Do you live in this world?By: Raj | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 17:22:39 PM Reply | Forward Mr. Nitin, how do you know one is European by his name. Do not be silly. Even if one is European, what it has to do with his statement. If you have a problem with what he says, attack his statement, not his name.

POTA or ATS for RSS kids?By: Raj | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 13:05:35 PM Reply | Forward That is it. If RSS does not manage to get majority to rule the country with Manu's rule, they will start a civil was and try to capture power. RSS can not tolerate democrac, equality, etc. They still support caste system and think some people are superior in quality just because of their caste. india will continue to suffer if thse manuvadis are not stopped. Rajnath should be arrested for anti-national speech (civil war). if Advani wants ATS to go because they arrested a terrorist of a particular community, why is he supporting POTA. Should the terrorosts that RSS trains be under POTA rather than ATS?

HINDU TERRARISMBy: SACHA BHARATIYA | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 20:12:44 PM Reply | Forward The congress governemnt is just spoiling the country. BJP at least differentiate between religion. but congress is most dangerous which finds sub divisions in the name of caste in all religions. Our country is divided less on religion and more in caste. First these politicians should learn nationalism istead of hinduism or any religion.Englishmen divided our country in the name of religion (FOOT DALO AUR RAJYA KARO) but for almost 50 years in power the congress party divided our country into different casts about which most of us dont know.The congress party used the british tactice of divide and rule and doing the same. First of all any politician doing politics on caste or religion should be punished.And some body above talking was talking about GUJARAT RIOTS. This was a reaction of GODHRA INCIDENT. Inefficieny of our legistlative system to take immediate action on terrorist increases frustration among affected group seeking justice, which result in counter-terrorism by the affected people. We are still protecting the terrorist who admitted to be involved in PARLIAMENT ATTACK, our goverment is spending our hard earned money in protecting them. ABOVE ALL KEEP THE POLITICIAN ASIDE, WE SHOULD LEARN TO RESPECT OTHER RELIGION AND SHOULD DECIDE NOT TO VOTE EITHER CONGRESS OR BJP, WE SHALL VOTE ONLY TO THE PERSON/PARTY WHO IS INTERESTED IN NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT. WE CAN SEE THE NATIONAL INTEREST LEVEL OF CONGRESS BY ITS SUPPORT TO PRATIBHA PATIL(NAMED IN FINANCE SCAM) INSTEAD OF SHRI APJ ABDUL KALAM whom no Indian National would reject. I Hope every Indian would accept presidential rule under the able leadership of Shri APJ ABDUL KALAM instead of democracy.

Wake up callBy: Ajit | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 13:02:09 PM Reply | Forward The way Advaniji and Rajnathji are getting panic on the investigations, there appears to be much more than what we see.It is high time the inteligent agencies take note of these thins and take some precautions and expose the full conspiracy.

Probe Advani's involvement in the blastsBy: Saeed Ahmed | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 12:56:37 PM Reply | Forward ATS please probe Advani's involvement in all the blasts that happened in INDIA since the independence. I think 90% of it would be done by Advani, I can say this by looking at his attitude towards the investigation. He is hypocrite and does not have any respect for India law. Let our ATS do their JOB.

ADVANI'S TAKEBy: INDIAN | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 18:35:50 PM Reply | Forward Are you a ISI agnent? I wonder if UPA government is making the job of ISI easier.

Adbvani wants ATS outBy: Jagdeep | Wednesday , 19 Nov '08 12:56:33 PM Reply | Forward Let the police do its job. If they are guilty let them face trial and be punsihed. Why does a political party interfere into the police matters. Not doing anything after the post godhra riots to ensure that the perperators are punished, Advani now wants the Malegaon terrorists to go scot free. Back off Mr. Advani - Let the police do its job.

PreviousNext1 2 3 4