Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
Channels Astrology | Cricket | Tenders | Classified | Blogs | Shopping | Opinions | Hotel| Travel
You are here: IE »   Story » Comment »

Its Bal Thackeray vs the Karkares over Kasab

Mumbai: In a veiled criticism of slain ATS chief Hemant Karkare's wife and daughter, Shiv Sena chief Bal Thackeray has said that the country does not share their stance that the lone 26/11 terrorist in Mumbai police custody should be let off on “humanitarian grounds”. “The Karkare family may have a dif  ....Read more

Comments
Post comment
82 Comments |
To do or not to do is the Question.By: Ravi | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 19:24:51 PM Reply | Forward Nehru said to Jinnah that ninety percent of Paksitanis were Hindus once upon a time when Jinnah responded that it was more like seventy percent.So Kasab might have been a Hindu so isnt it the battle of Mahabharat all over again?What would Lord Krishna advise Prince Arjuna if he was rulling India today?It is not question why but to do or die and one has to fight ones own kith and kin but the question is Kasab is a smal cog in the wheel.Isnt the war between India and Paksitan inevitable ? So why not go for the perpetrators and master minds,thier funders,planners whereever they may be?Catholic widows are allowed to marry others and so are Muslims who are allowed four wives.Some have suggested that if the white catholic lady ruller were to marry Pakistani widower ,late Benahzirs husband Zardari,then there may be peace between the two nations as late Emperor Akbar rulled India by having a Hindu and a Muslim wife.Food for thought
What makes senseBy: Anthony Joseph | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 19:22:28 PM Reply | Forward I think one ought to give the Karkare family the right to speak their mind. Whatever said and done Karkare's death has effected their family more than anybody else. For me hanging Kasab or putting him to life imprisonment or forgiving him because he repents for his actions are not of importance. What is important is to find out who is really behind this terror strikes, get to those and punish them. Kasab is no different from the gullible Marathi manoos that Thackrey and family have exploited all these years by fundamentally brainwashing them. So fundamentalist anywhere are the same, whether they are Christain, Hindu or Muslim. There is no better way to defeat terrorism but by pointing out to the whole world how hollow this whole game is and for that there is no better way but to forgive the person who is repentant. In this case I still have not heard anything like that coming either from Kasab or his parents.
Crocodile tearsBy: Ankit | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 18:58:24 PM Reply | Forward Mr. Thackrey instead of critisizing the slain cops widow, should learn the concept of humanity and forgiveness from her which he and his clan have never followed in their life. fortunately it was the same person who was branded anti national by these same forces for conducting investigation in malegaon blast, and now the crocodile tears.It's never late to start learning some humility when you have never demonstrated in your entire life. probably this exercise will allow him to spent some quality time understanding human values while leaving ordinary citizens to go about their life in peace instead of worying about riots and vandalism. Every one of us " The People of India" have equal and sacred right to have and to express our views. Many people in India may be too angry to accept Mrs. Karkare's view but atleast it clearly shows the basic difference between us and the terrorist and mad man lilke Mr Thackrey who only knows how to spill blood to achieve their political goal
aboveBy: janney | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 18:42:20 PM Reply | Forward May have fear, fear is the key
question to Mr. PurohitBy: Rohit | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 20:08:43 PM Reply | Forward Nobody at that time would have thought of Pakistanis crossing sea line and landing directly in Mumbai.You are the one who probably have been brainwashed from the child hood (by RSS) just like the terrorists who can do any thinggiven the frame of your insanity.Atleast respect the dead and his loving ones!There is a limit to what extent normal people can stoop to...Wow,look where fanatics can take us to...Narechi kela kiti heen nar.
PUBLICITY HUNGRY......By: AMIT PUROHIT | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 17:24:26 PM Reply | Forward THIS IN ITSELF SPEAKS HOW POWER AND PUBLICITY HUNGRY THIS FAMILY IS? KARKARE WAS ON POLITICAL DRILL OF CONGRESS.NOW HIS WIFE HAS BEEN ASSURED A TICKET FROM CONGRESS SO SHE IS ILLUDING PEOPLE AND INDIA, LIKE HER HUSBAND DID.BASICALLY THE MANNER IN WHICH KARKARE PUT HIMSELF BEFORE DEATH, IT IS CLEAR THAT HE WAS NON PROFESSIONAL AND HAD NO IDEA THAT WHAT IS THE INTENSITY OF ATTACK AND NATURE OF ATTACK.IN HIS THINKING IT MUST HAVE BEEN ANOTHER GANG WAR IN WHICH HE WOULD SHOOT OUT SOME GOONS AND HIS CREDIBILITY IN CASE HE WAS INVESTIGATING WOULD HAVE BEEN MEDIA CREDIBILITY PLUS BENEFITS FROM VEEBHATSA RAO DESHMUKH
PUBLICITY HUNGRY......By: mukesh | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 18:16:00 PM Reply | Forward Mr.AMIT PUROHIT, Would like to know your statement is as politician or a aamm citizen, I think you are speaking like thakare, what is your opanion about death of Major unikrishanan. I think you will call him also incompitent? when emergeny come noone wait for the goverment to give bullet proof jacket.If you are so superdoper next time such happens please sacarifiy your life.let a person who layed his life be in peace.
After whatBy: da Punjabi | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 18:45:20 PM Reply | Forward After what has happened in mumbai, i think Karkare life would have been a complete hell... There are so many questions still on the table. Some people are avoiding those question because of the mourning period for family. Plus, we are fighting diplomatic battle internationally against Pakistan. Kavita karkare should limit her exposure through media, because she is nobody. The family has been feeding off government by doing congress slavery...
WTF ?!?!By: WTF ?!?! | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 17:24:18 PM Reply | Forward Hang Kasab. At the same time, hang Thakrey. Another useless waste of space on the planet !!
wtf, wth?By: anju | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 21:40:10 PM Reply | Forward Finally, one sane voice in this whole discussion!
Hang T By: Surekha | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 17:56:39 PM Reply | Forward Why not garland Congress for all the bravery their unashamed stalwarts are exhibiting? On the same platform, if possible. Just go ahead, that's what you guys would love. Incredible I !
enemy gameBy: M.N.S.Nampoothiripad | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 17:20:20 PM Reply | Forward Mr Karkkare is the son of a leftist trade union AITUC Aleader, as revealed by Chandrachoodan, RSP general secretary. This is a clue. Somebody should investigate the entire ATS mission and the part played by the pseudo secular power centers in the whole game to tarnish the image of hindus. Mrs. Krkkare should not be a tool in the hands of the enemies of this nation any more.
Bal Thackrey was waiting for this opportunity? By: gary | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 17:09:01 PM Reply | Forward Thacreys know how to stay in limelight without any sufferings. He was hiding somewhere when terrorists attacked his home town and now he is out there to cliam the credit for everything, that he never did.
MAy be he also sleeping with a gun under a cushionBy: Govind | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 23:42:00 PM Reply | Forward May be he also sleeping with a gun under a cushion like Amitabh.They are just bunch of coward who can only Bark or hide
what were you doing GaryBy: Girish Nimbhorkar | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 17:32:07 PM Reply | Forward Well Gary its very easy to criticize Thakreys without knowing what they have done for the State or Mumbai in particular. These comments nowhere claim credit as such. But you people cannot tolerate growing strength of a Marathi manus and go on critisizing spree.
marathi manusBy: ghosh | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 17:56:57 PM Reply | Forward please dont rake up region now. the eyes of the relatives of all the martyrs are still not dry. is it a time to ask who is stronger manus? thakres have done nothing for marathis selflessly. he wanted fame and fortune in return. but the north indian soldier who died in mumbai laid down his life selflessly. please marathis wake up and be a greater indian than a stronger marathi.
KAVITHA KARKARA NOT MOURNING !!By: Thomas Varghese | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 16:58:40 PM Reply | Forward Kavitha Karkare is going to Trivandrum to attend Kairali (a communist organised event) function where playback singers will conduct a melodial programme. Is this the time for her to attend it? She is not from the clan of a Hindu culture. We consider all those killed as Karkare's and therefore one Karkare's children cannot decide for those 189 innocenets family.
r u a human beingBy: ramdas | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 19:43:45 PM Reply | Forward its neither karkares daughter or 189 victims childrens decision it has to be decided by the supreme court and then by the president.how come u dont have any shame/guilt before deriding ms karkare and lecturing on glories of widowhood.in lower castes they have to go to work the next day for their daily food. thank god there was one good thing for lower castes in the past and it was the absence of widowhood glories
KARKARE'S SACRIFICEBy: N.V.SANKARAN | Thursday , 8 Jan '09 16:57:33 PM Reply | Forward Mr. Hemant Karkare did not die fighting the terrorists, but was shot dead when he was proceding to the place of action, unlike Major Sandeep Unnikrishnan or Mr. Thukaram Rambole. Yet, it was very unfortunate. The coverage he got from the media was not because of any supreme sacrifice, but because he was responsible for finding "Hindu Terrorists". Unfortunately, his death does not clear the doubt that he was acting under pressure from somebody in relation to the Malegaon investigation. According to some earlier reports, he had complained that he was under great pressure. That pressure could very well have been from the UPA government since some of their cabinet ministers had demanded a ban on the Hindu organizations as a pre-condition for re-imposing the ban on SIMI. I think The ATS committed a big mistake by going public about suspected involvement of army personnel in the Malegaon blasts, instead of trusting the integrity of military authorities to conduct an impartial investigation
PreviousNext2345
Post a Comment
Name:
Email:
Title:
Maximum characters allowed     
Comment:
TERMS OF USE:
The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
I agree to the terms of use.