Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
Channels Astrology | Cricket | Tenders | Classified | Blogs | Shopping | Opinions | Hotel| Travel
You are here: IE »   Story » Comment »

PC caught in row as Jamiat speaks out against Vande Mataram

Deoband (UP)/New Delhi: On a day that Union Home Minister P Chidambaram was attending, the 30th general session of the Jamiat Ulama-e-Hind on Tuesday sparked off a controversy when one of the 25 resolutions passed by it asked Muslims not to recite the Vande Mataram, on the grounds that some verses of the national song  ....Read more

Comments
Post comment
54 Comments |
Patriotism hurtBy: Deb | Thursday , 5 Nov '09 11:54:18 AM Reply | Forward If Vande Mataram is not sung by a community then that amounts to showing disrespect to the nation.This shows how these people are trying to create rifts between people who adhere to the faith of nationality and people who do not.Christinaity is also a monotheistic religion and it also primarily goes against any sort of idol worship. But Christians didn,t show any dissent against the national song.People who would speak or decline from singing our national song should be expelled from this country because of their unpatriotic nature.Islamists over thyears thathey hate this very system of democracy or multiculturalism which all other faiths have accepted to live in. Their very rigid nature and overall backwardness and along with few of our politicians countinously ignoring their misdeeds only to appease them will eventually prove to be detrimental for this country.
Mr. A.R. REHMAN composed music for this song... Just a songBy: Raj | Wednesday , 4 Nov '09 18:26:55 PM Reply | Forward His music added another dimension to it. These politicians are adopting Divide and Rule policy. They create problem for people of this nation, create problem with people of neighboring nations like Pakistan and China. They have no means to create Peace and Progress. They can not win in their own country, who will listen to them in foreign soil. DO not listen to them my friends.
Vande MataramBy: Gouri | Wednesday , 4 Nov '09 16:50:02 PM Reply | Forward This is simply a non issue which is projected as an issue. Nobody is bothered who is pronouncing VANDE MATARAM or not. The glory of VANDE MATARAM never diminishes. Linking VANDE MATARAM with religious sentiments is a profitable business for the Congress, CPIM, CPI and BJP who have proved that end always matters for them, not the means.
Great Fatwa...By: Abdul Raafi | Wednesday , 4 Nov '09 16:01:23 PM Reply | Forward Really its Great Fatwa.....Every Muslims should be very cleat about this....I expect more fatwa like this......
Need Action, not words.By: Dusty Jasad | Wednesday , 4 Nov '09 15:11:42 PM Reply | Forward Love for the nation is action "DOING". Not singing or talking. I had a teacher is school who beat the Muslims boys black and blue for not singing Vande Mataram in the moring assembly. In end he was caught and convicted of leaking exam papers in return for money.
Not Anti-Islamic but no compulsion should be made, yes VM is reflecting hinduismBy: venky | Wednesday , 4 Nov '09 14:29:05 PM Reply | Forward VM is hindu patriotic song and that's why it was not put as national anthem. But the translation did not reflect anti-islamism in any way. I think the best solution to it is: -a) VM should not be compulsory anywhere.b) An urdu song may be selected and added as a national song with islamic reflections.c) Clarification may be sought on this fatwa so that hindu sentiments may not be disturbed.Chidambaram's silence could be a concern but replying immediately could be a bigger concern. Let's not complain him on this matter.
Rama and the Arab worldBy: durrukh | Wednesday , 4 Nov '09 14:13:49 PM Reply | Forward Is the Arabic month RAMA DAN [RAMAZAN] a tribute to Rama???Is the second son of Noah [HAM] is the same person as RAM ??? like SIND is wrongly pronounced as HIND and finally transmitted to INDIA???[Geneology and brief history of the sons of Noah]
VM English translationBy: Aliex | Wednesday , 4 Nov '09 13:54:45 PM Reply | Forward Portion of Vande Mataram which Islam does not recognize...Vande Mataram song is embeded with Hindusim in it. But Islam does respects the views of this song.Thou art Durga, Lady and Queen, With her hands that strike and her swords of sheen, Thou art Lakshmi lotus-throned, And the Muse a hundred-toned, Pure and perfect without peer, Mother lend thine ear, Rich with thy hurrying streams, Bright with thy orchard gleems, Dark of hue O candid-fair
Vande Mataram is not anti-islamic or monotheismBy: vijay | Wednesday , 4 Nov '09 13:51:05 PM Reply | Forward Vande mataram cannot be considered to be anti-islamic because singing that you worship the figurative mother can also be considered as saying that you worship the figurative allah, if you merely consider the words only (allah and mother) as interchangable. The reasoning here is that any object of worship can also be considered as allah and therefore it is not anti-islamic.
Fatwa should be democratic in a democratic countryBy: sandeep | Wednesday , 4 Nov '09 13:38:39 PM Reply | Forward Fatwa should be democratic in a democratic country like India,It only shows conservationist approach....Muslims are equal in India and this is the time(seeing the instability in region) we have to show more unity by not to bound to such narrow mind dividing power
Next1234
Post a Comment
Name:
Email:
Title:
Maximum characters allowed     
Comment:
TERMS OF USE:
The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
I agree to the terms of use.