|
Two Punjabi non-romantics may succeed
Shekhar Gupta
MALE, May 11: The arrival of the South Asian heads of state in Male marked
the end of the league phase of the ninth SAARC (South Asian Association
Regional Cooperation) summit.
Actually there was never any doubt as to the final line up. the business of
SAARC summitry has always been a sideshow for India-Pakistan talks. But
never since the 1988 Rajiv-Benazir ``honeymoon'' summit, so heady and
finally so disastrous, have expectations been raised to such a pitch. That
is why it is important to read the bad news right now: don't expect any
earth-shattering breakthroughs just now.
The good news, however, is that nobody is expecting breakthroughs of the
kind promised in 1988. The new catchphrase is a step-by-step solution. And
if this step merely results in the two leaders agreeing to meet again soon
and their respective spokesmen not ending up calling each other names it
will be seen as a gain.
The political and security environment in the subcontinent is today more
suitable for a resolution now than in 1988: The Pakistani democracy is
stronger and the leadership more confident; India has discovered the
confident self-belief of a country that always took pride in its ability to
defeat internal conflicts. Shadow of Khalistan is a forgotten nightmare, and
Kashmir, if the rapidly dropping level of combat there is any indication,
seems to be on the mend. Both countries are rapidly reforming their
economies and would prefer not to be distracted by old blood feuds. But the
most important difference between 1997 and 1988 is that the key
interlocutors today are no romantics either in terms of their diplomacy or
mutual chemistry.
So don't expect, this time around, leaders addressing a joint press
conference stealing furtive, shy glances, exchanging blushes and sharing
sweet nothings.
It may not be a fashionable notion in India but if this summit has a more
realistic chance of succeeding, though in a limited sense, it is because
since Zia-ul-Haq's days it is the first time India will be dealing with a
Pakistani leader who is in control. He cannot barter Kashmir away, nor even
talk of settling along the Line of Control. But possibly, and hopefully, he
won't have to worry now about his own army and intelligence bugging the room
where the talks are held and then releasing the tapes to his political
rivals.
The notion that is indeed fashionable in India, of a weak Gujral leading a
fractious coalition and desperate to show gains for his own new foreign
policy doctrine giving away too much too soon, fortunately, is misplaced.
The limitations the political situation in India creates also gives Gujral
the negotiating space.
He can, and most likely will, tell Nawaz Sharif to wait and be patient. That
a coalition, as he must know from his own experience, makes it impossible
for its leader to take major decisions in a hurry. So why not begin with the
more possible things instead, like opening up trade, people-to-people
contact, a real agreement on not bashing up diplomats, on suspending the
sickening old game of competitive cussedness?
It is difficult to promise Sharif will listen. He too will be surrounded by
old Cold Warriors from his own foreign office who would continue to remind
him that Kashmir is the core issue, that any other way to treat the disease
is akin to mere aspirin therapy for a disease defying cure for a half
century.
But look at the stakes Sharif has in this summit. He ran, and won, a whole
election campaign without mentioning Kashmir not because he has become a
peacenik. He did it because he knew that if he had to become a real prime
minister he had to defang the army, the power of the Eighth Amendment that
it exercised through the President and he wasn't going to be able to do it
on a politically sustainable basis until Kashmir was taken off the
frontburner. He is not about to give away Pakistan's claims on Kashmir. But
he would prefer if his own extra-parliamentary establishment is denied its
greatest leverage within his country's power structure.
Already the build-up to this summit, the league phase, has been
qualitatively different from any in the past. It is the undoubtedly the
first summit where India has not been isolatedly fighting at least four of
the remaining six (with the customary exception of Bhutan and Maldives)
simultaneously. Slowly, diplomacy in South Asia too is acquiring a strong
trade and economic dimension and the idea of sub-regional groupings, driven
by economics and isolating Pakistan as it has so far refused to play along
with the move towards a common trading zone has already caused consternation
in Islamabad.
The new mood among the Bangladeshi, Nepalese and the Sri Lankan delegations
is a tangible gain from the Gujral Doctrine. It doesn't automatically follow
that the tactics will play out exactly the same way with Pakistan. But when
the subcontinent's first ever Punjabi summiteers meet in its most expensive
and exotic beach resort at Kurumba (coconut) island tomorrow, the topmost
question on their minds will be the same now to sidestep Kashmir without
letting the people back home know and get on with the business.
Copyright © 1997 Indian Express Newspapers (Bombay) Ltd.
|