Have a flair with words?

Search
Elections '99

The Indian Express

The Financial Express

Latest News

Screen

Express Computer
Feedback
Mythology

CerfKids

Corporate Results

Ebate

Matrimonials

Careers

Lifestyle

Astrology

E-Cards

Columnists

Graffiti

Crossword

Letters

Jewellery
Info-tech

Power

Steel


INDIAN EXPRESS FRONT PAGE

Politics

Business

Expressions

General

World

Sports

Leisure

States

 

Friday, October 8, 1999

Gujarat, Rajasthan in tug of war over plot

ROHIT BHAN  
MANGARH, OCT 7: The phrase no man's land could have been coined for the desolate 350 acres crowning a hill on the Gujarat-Rajasthan border. Home to no one, fairground for the populace of the surrounding villages, Mangarh is fast getting caught up in a tug of war between the two state governments.

The sensitivity of the issue is further accentuated by the religious significance attached to the place by the Bhil tribals residing in the Bhanvar and Kunda villages (undisputably in Gujarat) and Anandipuri village of Rajasthan. They believe that Guru Gobindji had fought a battle with the British here in 1912 -- every year in March, hundreds of tribals congregate at a fair to mark the occasion.

Interestingly, this fair is a major reason why both governments are reluctant to give up claim to the hill; both want to develop it into an annual tourist attraction. As of today, tribals of the three neighbouring villages shoulder the responsibility of organising the mela, while the Rajasthan and Gujarat police jointlytake care of the security. ``Since people from both Rajasthan and Gujarat attend the mela, it becomes a joint responsibility,'' says Dahod Collector E.I. Kalashva.

While the tribals themselves are oblivious as to who owns the land, officials of both states seem to be trying to checkmate the other. Some years ago, the Rajasthan government constructed a gram panchayat building on the hill and followed it up in 1998 by putting up a board of its literacy campaign.

The Gujarat government, loath to be left behind, inaugurated a dharamshala right next to the gram panchayat building in March this year. According to Kalashva, the dharamshala was meant expressly for tribals coming to the mela.

If these buildings are mere symbols, development is a victim of unclear jurisdiction. Significantly enough, it is the Rajasthan government that laid the first road to Mangarh. But Kalashva says a road to make Mangarh accessible from Gujarat was being built. ``Almost four kms have been laid; the road will be complete by theend of the year,'' he adds.

Interestingly enough, both states base their claims to the Mangarh hill on history. ``Government gazettes clearly state that Mangarh belongs to Gujarat,'' says Kalashva. ``We have sent them (the Rajasthan government) scores of communiques, along with copies of the gazettes, stating that Mangarh belongs to Gujarat.''

Retorts Banswada (Rajasthan) Collector Suraj Mal Meena, ``The historical gazettes in our possession clearly state that it is our land.''About the only encouraging sign in this impasse is the two collectors' admission that the conflict needs to be resolved. ``Both governments are seized of the matter. Forest, collectorate and police officials of both states will meet soon to discuss the matter,'' say Kalashva and Meena.

So where does it leave the people? In much the same place they have occupied all these years. ``It doesn't matter who the land belongs to. It's significant to us because our guru fought a war here,'' says Gorji Pargi of Bhanvar village. AgreesDhansukhbhai of Anandipuri, ``To us, borders are unimportant. We revere this place and will continue to visit it even if the record books say it belongs to Gujarat.''

That, in fact, is the way it has been all these years. According to locals, it is ``outsiders'' who are blowing the issue out of proportion. Among the guilty, they name a former Rajasthan MLA, who has put up a statue of himself in Mangarh, and frequently voices his state's claim to the land. Undoubtedly, there are similar die-hard claimants on the Gujarat side of the border as well.

Copyright © 1999 Indian Express Newspapers (Bombay) Ltd.


Top

Call India at 30c/m

123india.com: Join the chat
 

Click here for a printer-friendly page Printer-friendly page



EXPRESSindia.com
Elections '99
News   Business   Sports   Entertainment
The Indian Express | The Financial Express | Latest News | Screen | Express Computers
Matrimonials | Careers | Lifestyle | Mythology | Astrology
E-Cards | Graffiti | Columnists | Ebate | Jewellery | Cerfkids
Corporate Results | Info-tech | Power