You are here: IE »   Story

1984 riots: Life in jail for three

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • Discount UK Shopping
    In the first case of such stern punishment in the 1984 anti-Sikh riot case, a city court on Saturday sentenced three men to rigorous imprisonment for life under charges of attempt to murder, loot and arson.

    The trio — Brij Mohan Verma, Mangal Sain and Bhagat Singh — were also slapped with a monetary penalty of Rs 6.2 lakh each.

    Additional Sessions Judge (ASJ) Surinder S Rathi held that the convicts had to be given the maximum punishment for their acts of “mindless violence committed under the garb of emotional outburst.”

    The convicts were immediate neighbours of victim Joginder Singh in Shastri Nagar, North Delhi. On November 1, 1984, the three barged into Singh’s house, beat up the family and looted the house before putting it on fire.

    The incident forced Singh and his sons Jagmohan and Gurinder to migrate to Amritsar soon after. They took the witness box during the trial, which helped the court seal the fate of the accused.   

    Ads by Google

    In his order, ASJ Rathi described the anti-Sikh riots as the “most unfortunate time” for the country after Independence.

    “I see no justification in claiming that the riots were emotional outburst of masses,” he observed. “There can be no justification, verbose or otherwise, to validate such mayhem and pogrom.”

    The court also held that it was “alarming and disturbing” that the convicts committed the crime despite being neighbours.

    The court also slammed the state machinery for mishandling the situation and failing to protect the victims’ families.

    “History would never forgive police officials who were at the helm of the affairs and the government of the day for their unprecedented slothful and quiescent role,” ASJ Rathi said.

    “But for the contrived action and sluggish response of the police and the government, scores of priceless lives could have been saved.”

    Finding substance in the arguments of special prosecutor Irfan Ahmed, the court held that the trio’s punishment must serve as a lesson for others.    

    Victims Jagmohan Singh and Gurinder Singh were present in court today. Expressing apology to the brothers for the overstretched trial, ASJ Rathi said though no monetary

    relief could undo their pain, Rs 18 lakh would be given to them out of the penalty amount as token of compensation.

    Jagmohan Singh told Newsline after the verdict that he was satisfied with the judgment as it would serve as a precedent for others.

    “I feel vindicated and satisfied that there is still scope for justice in the country,” he said.

    His younger brother Gurinder said he had wanted his father, who passed away in 1990, to see the guilty being punished.

    Dubbing the verdict as “unprecedented,” a senior official from the Anti-Riots Cell said it was the first case in the Capital where convicts were handed down life imprisonment under charges of attempt to murder.

    Still a long way to goBy: Anil Kohli | 30-Aug-2009 Reply | Forward Dear Mr.Utkarsh Anand,This is appalling, after 25years 3 persons have been sentenced for a genocide, planned and executed by a party, which has formed the maximum number of Governments in this country since Independence. What is intriguing is that you are making a big deal out this sentencing, which is for attempt to murder etc etc. What about the 3000 Sikhs who were massacred? Who killed them? What is being done to bring those criminals to book? When will the victims get justice? These should have been the points on which you should have stressed rather than highlight 3 individual being punished for Attempt to Murder as if it was just another routine crime story.Is the print media still in a mould to save the real culprits, and wants to avoid any embarrassment being caused to the Congress Party, for orchestrating the most heinous crime against innocent Indian Citizens and that too in the National Capital. What wrong had these 3000 Sikhs done? That they deserved the fate that visited them.
    Not the end but a begining and a strong message.. By: Utkarsh Anand | 12-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward Dear Mr Kohli,my story did not aim merely at making a big deal out of the punishment awarded to three of the guilty persons but attempted to point out that while number of other cases relating to graver offences like murder committed during the riots are still pending, there is still a ray of hope with a court not closing its eyes from the gravity of the offence against scores of innocent citizens. I realise what we have is not a very pleasant judicial experience as far as 1984 cases are concenrned but if a judge does something, like in this case extraordinary, is not the duty of the media to highlight it so that other courts cannot shut their eyes towards the obligation of delivering justice? Moreover, Indian Express has always been underscoring the trauma of all the victims awaiting justice in 1984 cases and I promise that we will never evade our duties as a media. I shall alaso request you to read other stories published by Express on 1984 cases, clearly reflecting we have been very vocal about every aspect. Thank you for your comment..
    InexcuseableBy: Jas | 01-Nov-2009 Reply | Forward Mr Anand,I greatly appreciate Indians like you and paper like IE for excercising the freedoms that the system rightfully bestows but I am extremely bitter about the fact that vast majority of Indians are mentally slave to anyone they see in power. In a country of well informed and thinking people, the polically powerful indivitals like Mrs Gandhi and later her son could never have done what they did to Sikhs on extremely flimsy grounds. Even, being an atheist( or agnostic at best),I find it impossible to excuse what these two indivituals did. I also find the action of larger Indian society, subsequent governments, judiciary, administrative, intelligence and police services equally inexcusable. It is disgustingly sick to listen to some SOBs polical and religious leaders telling Sikhs patronisingly to forget what happened to them. Instead of promoting Mrs Gandhi and Rajib as great leaders, they should be treated as modern Ravans, the incarnations of evil who paid for their sins. Now that would be some lesson worth imparting to posterity. But that will not happen in the nation consiting of ignorant Hindus, Muslims, Sikh and Christians but very few well-meaning humans.
    What about the others?By: Preetam Singh | 30-Aug-2009 Reply | Forward What about the political party whose leaders went about supplying petrol and matchboxes for burning the Sikhs? What about their leader who shrugged off the riots saying,"When a banyan tree falls,the earth shakes!"
    1984 roitsBy: Jagmohan Germany | 30-Aug-2009 Reply | Forward When will Tytler be punished.maybe never.By punishing small criminals BALLI KA BAKRA the courts cannot wipe the tears of the SIKHS
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.