Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

‘A few black sheep don’t make the entire Indian Army corrupt’

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • The image of the Army has taken a beating recently. Earlier, it was for professional incompetence but after media reports exposed corruption among senior officers, fake killings and recruitment scams have shattered the image of Army as an honest and professional organisation.

    While there are certainly a few corrupt elements in the Army, it is unfortunate that certain sections of the media are portraying entire Armed Forces as a corrupt institution.

    Till a decade ago, associating the word corruption with Forces was considered a taboo as media felt it could demoralise them. Today, media houses are competing with each other to twist corruption cases linked with Army and discrediting the institution in its entirety.

    While none can justify the incidences of corruption in the Army, mistaking a few black sheep with the entire flock is neither appropriate nor acceptable. It is not possible to isolate the Army from the degeneration of moral fibre that has been accepted by the society as our fate for years. Very few take pride in being upright and talking straight. Courage, integrity and morality have been the major casualties in recent times giving way to hypocrisy and sycophancy and the Armed Forces have not remained untouched.

    Ads by Google

    No system can remain foolproof in such times as designing a fair system is one and letting it function effectively quite another. Vested interests don’t let the system function, as the babu and politician combine ultimately controls the introduction of any major weapon system or equipment in the Army. Procurement of any equipment depends upon various factors including urgency, quantities required, import cost, production with foreign collaboration and indigenous development. However, the system which attempts to integrate many agencies like DGMO (Director General Military Operations), DGMI (Director General Military Intelligence), ADGWE(Assistant Director General Weapons and Equipment) , DGQA(Director General Quality Assurance), DGSD, Ordnance, MOD in the procurement process of equipment tends to become unnecessarily complex and unwieldy.

    ... contd.

    Next1234
    The flock is blackBy: Col Anil Kaul, VrC (Retd) | 08-Nov-2009 Reply | Forward Sir, It would be naive to call the article correct in so far as a few black sheep are concerned. Unfortunately and I am not being cynical, a time is fast approaching where the entire flock will turn black and white sheep will be the exceptions. I say it because the Armed Forces are from the very same society that throw up its Satyam's and Koda's, The difference is in its scope and magnitude of operations.Also the one who gets caught is called a black sheep whereas scores of others keep making merry. The problem lies in our selection to higher ranks that unfortunately is based on personal merit as against professional merit. An introspection will reveal that weak and unfit commanders will only allow their ilk to survive & prosper. Correct this anomoly and all your flock will turn White.
    Must clean up the mess at higher levelsBy: Brig Kiran Krishan (Retd) | 08-Nov-2009 Reply | Forward It is ironic we should even be bothered about shielding the guilty from anyone, media included. Our threshold for tolerating greedy officers should even be less than for those at lower levels. Corruption often hidden as misuse of resources is sapping the vitals of the army, and making servicemen insiduously tolerant of a life thretening malady. As it is, most people now tend to believe that an honest Indian is one who doesn't get an opportunity.
    ‘A few black sheep don’t make the entire Indian Army corrupt’By: Maj Gen Raj Mehta | 07-Nov-2009 Reply | Forward It is churlish to paint a 1.3 million strong Army black, because a few of its representatives have resorted to un- officer like conduct. On the contrary, the media should appreciate the fact that the Army does not hush up these cases of errant behaviour and almost invariably ensures speedy and substantial punishment of those found guilty of abusing their sacred covenant. Army officers command their soldiers lives on trust; something no other Government functionary does and the vast majority live and die by the unique soldiers ethos of izzat-o-iqbal. The few who break this trust deserve stringent punishment and public disgrace. The Army has repeatedly shown its capacity to do so, and needs to be lauded for its uncompromising attitude in this regard. I do not accept the criticism that Army standards are declining in line with declining civilian standards. The Army does not look upon civilians to set its standards but lives and dies by its own, unique, self sacrificing ethos.
    ‘A few black sheep don’t make the entire Indian Army corrupt’By: Sqn Ldr Rana TS Chhina | 07-Nov-2009 Reply | Forward An army is at best a reflection of the State that it serves. The article highlights certain valid points. An important aspect that has been missed out is widespread State apathy towards the morale of its soldiers. A case in point is the lack of a proper National War Memorial to commemorate our war dead. As for Col Premendra Singh's appeal for politically correct colour-blindness above, I would invoke the bard (of Avon): "What's in a name? That which we call a rose, By any other name would smell as sweet." Romeo and Juliet (II, ii, 1-2); or the Sard (of Bhatinda): "Sirji, ki farak painda?"
    ‘A few black sheep don’t make the entire Indian Army corrupt’By: Lt Col Premendra Singh | 07-Nov-2009 Reply | Forward [1] It is basically wrong and politically incorrect to id 'black sheep' as defaulters. Why not 'white sheep' ? What term would the 'colours of the rainbow' South African Army use ? Or the Nigerian Army ? [2] A black, pink, white or brown Labrador dog is same to same Sir, in performance and fidelity. The black and silver Angelfish in my aquarium are equally quarrelsome at feeding time. And so on. [3] The Indian civilian transport department should also ban that favourite on truck behinds "Boori Nazar wala, tera mooh kala"
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.