However, determination of the market value is subject to the collector’s discretion and can only be questioned by the courts — a drawnout process that few of the aggrieved can resort to. Nor, thanks to asymmetry in information, are land-owners privy to what might be an appropriate market price. In determining a fair compensation, the law also prevents courts from considering an increase in the value of the land after acquisition, resulting from subsequent change in land use or improvements.

There are separate issues such as the fear of livelihood loss, the lack of adequate skills, compounded by the lack of a resettlement and rehabilitation policy.

Any contract can seem immoral if land prices increase dramatically after a contract to sell has been executed.

It is an issue of information dissemination and transparency in decision-making processes. This is the backdrop against which the Punjab government’s Rs 1.5 crore per acre to farmers in Jhurheri village for the Chandigarh international airport needs to be viewed — a princely sum compared with what Punjab and Haryana have offered earlier. Had the Punjab government offered Rs 64 lakh per acre (as it did to Chilla farmers for the knowledge city in Mohali), Jhurheri village might well have accepted, especially since farming is no longer attractive.

The point is that by providing a more generous package, the Punjab administration not only handled potential resentment better, but it also provided a better information environment for Punjab’s farmers to operate in.

This assumes additional significance because, apart from public acquisition, private land sales in adjoining areas are also possible, which will now reflect more realistic prices.

In addition, incentives (waiver of registration fees, stamp duties, priority power connections) have been thrown in. However, Punjab’s largefarmer and Green Revolution agriculture is not representative of Indian agriculture. It is not obvious that a better information environment will be sufficient elsewhere in India. It is, however, necessary