Tall claims

The crux of the shenanigans at SHCIL over the last few months is the lucrative picking expected from Central Record Keeping for the e-stamping project in collaboration with Crimson Logic Pte Ltd of Singapore. Some numbers explain why this is such a juicy contract. The total stamp duty collected by all the states during 2004-05 has been estimated at Rs 17,644 crore, of which five states, viz Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh, accounted for a total collection of Rs10,201 crore, ie almost 60 per cent of the total duty. Maharashtra is reported to have collected Rs 3,375 crore, Uttar Pradesh Rs 2,564 crore, Karnataka Rs 1,600 crore, Tamil Nadu Rs 1,350 crore and Andhra Pradesh Rs 1,312 crore. The maximum stamp duty in the country is collected from Mumbai, which is considered the financial capital. The SHCIL management has quietly worked to ensure that the oversight of this project is completely diffused, by routing the technology contract through two layers of subsidiaries.

Vigilance rules?

Meanwhile, the dubious deals at SHCIL do not stop at tampering with the shareholding or spawning clandestine subsidiaries. Our sources reveal that its sr. vigilance manager, PramodKumar D Pramanik, a former police officer, has been accused in a case connected with the issue of an illegal passport to Aminabi Kaskar, the mother of gangster Dawood Ibrahim. The matter relates to 1995 and documents available with us show that a CBI inquiry led to a case being filed before the additional chief metropolitan magistrate on 19th June, 2002. Since 2005, Pramanik and two others have been fighting to have the criminal cases filed against them quashed. The first filed a criminal revision application before the Sessions court, which was rejected in May 2006. The same year they filed an application (3701 of 2006) before the Bombay High Court. We had brought this to the attention of Sebi over a week ago. Interestingly, Mr Pramanik had joined SHCIL on a contract and was later taken on as its permanent staff member. It will be interesting to find out if there was ever a background check by the personnel department or his antecedents cross-verified with a former police commissioner who is a consultant to SHCIL. More pertinently, does the government ensure that organisations, which are handed sensitive contracts such as e-stamping, have proper HR policies. After all, the Telgi scandal, which has led to the e-stamping initiative, exposed the deep involvement of several senior police officials cutting across state boundaries.

... contd.