Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

America’s learning curve

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • What struck me about the coverage of the Obama Phenomenon in the Indian media was a certain tendency of self-deprecation. Some people bemoaned that India does not have a transformational leader like Obama. They were full of praise for America. There is nothing wrong with praising America where praise is due. But in doing so, they also berated India, saying how Indian society is stagnant and resistant to change. They seem to find nothing good in Indian society, nothing reformative in our history, and nothing progressive in our national values.

    Let us get some basic facts clear, facts that show how slow and halting America’s own march to progress. When Obama was born in 1961, the marriage between his Black Kenyan father and White American mother was illegal in as many as 19 out of 50 states in the US. The Constitution of India, on the other hand, enshrined, in 1950 itself, equality as one of the foundational principles of our newly independent nation—equality of rights and freedoms of every Indian, cutting across their racial, religious or caste identities. Dr B.R. Ambedkar belonged to a caste that was previously treated as “untouchable”. But his brilliance ensured no prejudice came in the way of his becoming the principal architect of the Indian Constitution. Could this have been possible in the United States?

    Ads by Google

    When Obama was growing up, segregation between Whites and Blacks in public places was still an ugly reality in America. In many states, Blacks stood at the back in buses. They drank at separate water fountains reserved for ‘Coloureds’. At restaurants they couldn’t sit on the same tables as the Whites.

    ... contd.

    PreviousNext1234
    ExcellentBy: Harish | 16-Nov-2008 Reply | Forward Excellent article
    Faltu and void of facts articleBy: Sunita Nair | 16-Nov-2008 Reply | Forward Lol, dumb analysis by a dumb emotional fool. I know this comment is not going to be published, but at least I know the author will know my view of this stupid article.One thing definitely is that Obama is no Sun and Lies has been his forte all along the campaign. I assure you his is going to be the worst administration and India is not going to be spared. All you pseudo intellectuals are going to get burnt by this Liar.
    Obama..the manBy: Bharavi | 18-Nov-2008 Reply | Forward I can understand your frustration as you voted for John McCain (and Hillary C before that)...hee hee hee. But the article is not about Obama. Its about how America has changed and has an ability to learn from its experiences. Obama may turn out to be a failure (I pray not) but so what ? Americans will vote him out after 4 yrs and learn from this experience too and will be more careful next time. But at the present moment, he is the man and he inspires hope in all Americans. And that is the greatest advantage America has today. When did you see such inspiration in so many people around the world? (Except may be when the Berlin wall came down .. then too the Soviet bloc wasn't so happy). Don't be too cynical and enjoy the moment.
    Faltu and void of facts articleBy: Sunita Nair | 16-Nov-2008 Reply | Forward Lol, dumb analysis by a dumb emotional fool. I know this comment is not going to be published, but at least I know the author will know my view of this stupid article.One thing definitely is that Obama is no Sun and Lies has been his forte all along the campaign. I assure you his is going to be the worst administration and India is not going to be spared. All you pseudo intellectuals are going to get burnt by this Liar.
    America’s learning curveBy: Sameer | 16-Nov-2008 Reply | Forward Lets face certain truths1)"But his brilliance ensured no prejudice came in the way of his becoming the principal architect of the Indian Constitution.".This was possible only because India was under British rule.Indian society had heaped enough humiliations on him so that he even decided to give up Hinduism.Also the current position of Dalits in India is pathetic.2 ) It is absurd logic to say that we have three muslim presidents.In India president is lame duck and is a mere constitutional head and he is not elected by popular vote unlike the US president.If we had a Muslim prime minister it would have been a different matter.Agreed America is by no means perfect but instead of patting ourselves on the back , lets face the harsh realities of large scale corruption, hunger and divisions based on language,caste and religion and lets work towards improving India with humility not arrogance
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.