opinion
by Indian on 2009-01-06 12:12:03.527327+05:30
It was very natural to react in a way our officers reacted. Why make hue and cry on their travelling together. By any known record of terrorist attack, terrorists were known to hide in a place not moving freely around the city on road. It was beyond anyone's imagination that terrorists will be on road wide exposed to any reaction from our security force. They were at CST and when they could not find place to hide in CST, they left the place . It was a shear coincidence that they met with our officers on their way to next destination and since our officers were not ready for such behavior from terrorists and were not equipped with weapons to face head on with terrorist equpped with AK 47 or so, met with a unfortunate end. If you think rationally, the whole episode was very natural in iself wherein we lost very efficient officers of our country. We are proud of them but equally sad that even encounter speciallists are not provided with sophisticated weapons to protect them
Talking about mystery
by agd on 2008-12-17 20:59:16.318025+05:30
was watching video footage on youtube just after Mr Karkare was killed, in that footage it was apparent that the terrorists were in a police van and not hiding behind some trees or bushes like most news sites were broadcasting. The van was supposed to have been taken after killing the top cops . Mr Karkare was a smart man and to reach the level he was at you either have to be corrupt or have to be really smart. I don't think he was corrupt. Now the question of landing at the place in the situation he was in and with the police van taken over by the terrorists before the attack on the top cops does not add up, inside betrayal.(Search for Terrorist fired from a police van in youtube)
ABC Murders
by act on 2008-12-06 15:35:56.914672+05:30
ABC MurdersThis one has all the aspects of Agatha Cristie's "The ABC Murders" written all over it. The C murder (Karkare and colleagues) was the objective, while the rest were distractions to confuse everyone on the real motive.
Karkare's Murder was Planned
by Mirza on 2008-12-02 00:21:32.743881+05:30
I Believe Karkare's death was planned. He was called at the Taj so he could be killed. The BJP is the direct beneficiary from this terror attack. They would gain power and get rid of True Indian policemen. Karkare was one honest and true Indian Policeman. The Jews were also highlited in this whole issue out of nowhere. They want to gain sympathy once again. The jews are now teaching some dirty politics to the already dirty BJP. The jews like to use india as they used america and live on india as a parasite. Please wake up people.
Sick mindset
by Sam on 2008-12-22 15:03:05.547932+05:30
Such a sick mindset can exist only with these kinds of people.They are completely innocent, and all the blame is with Hindus or Jews
Murder of officers a conspiracy...
by Sufiyan on 2008-12-01 18:55:56.222432+05:30
It was a very sad moment for our country when it lost 3 of its honest officers in the dastardly Mumbai attack. ATS chief Hemant Karkare was a dedicated officer and he had also proved that the ATS in Mumbai is not biased and it is not controlled by some politicians or vested interests. The investigations in the Malegaon blasts were evident enough that some anti social elements wanted to carry out blasts in parts of the country by blaming the muslim community. If Hemant Karkare would have survived, then a lot of new evidences would sprut out at this time, but it is sad to say that honest people are always surrounded by enemies. The assisination of these police officers was a well planned conspiracy and i fear to say that this mystery will vanish forever if it comes under the hands of corrupted and communal police officers. At this point of time all the people of Maharashtra irrespective of their caste creed and religion must unite together and may God bless all those departed souls.
We Must Act
by PeaceMaker on 2008-11-29 23:55:54.207011+05:30
Salute to these People....We must learn from what has happened in Mumbai.....how shocking is it that only 12 people has bought the mighty empire on it knees...its the time when we have to act...at any cost...
Witnees account of Karkare's death.
by Anwar A.M on 2008-11-29 22:48:13.834062+05:30
Sir,We need to protect Arun Jadhav being the only eye witness to the grusome kiiling of our Hero Karkare as this incident has to be thoroughly investigated. I am afraid the forces who killed Karkare might also kill Arun Jadhav. May God Almighty Bless the widow and family of Karkare and other martyres.
The dirty Politics Game!
by MM on 2008-11-29 22:26:41.205656+05:30
Karkare's Death was well planned in the shadow of terrorism. The incident took place when the whole country was behind the Malegaon blast and this was the very suitable
Witness account of Karkare, Kamte and Salaskar’s death
by Suresh Rao on 2008-11-29 22:18:41.18151+05:30
Absolutly horrifying as to how the 3 top cops were togetherin one place while going for an operation. The first rule is NEVER travel together lest anything happened .This is riutinely followed everywhere and yet our top cops ignored it at their own peril God !!! we are truly such an unlucky country to loose all the top three.
Please understand
by Venkat on 2008-11-29 20:36:06.683618+05:30
The circumstances leading to the death of the three top Police officers in India( please read India) in a split second should make us think --what made all the three officers go in a single van..what was the message given to them...was there a talk of terrorist attack already and not just the injury of a PC? We have to look at the entire episode of the attacks on Mumbai and not just the attack on the police officers to understand better the conspiracy...there is no doubt about the quality and commitment of our police officers...THEY ARE HEROS...there is something more that has happened and we have to look for that...is the attack a distraction? It's easy to point fingers(with all that has happened in the past) at our neighboring countries for a good reason...but our suspicion should not start and end with Pakistan..we have to look at incidents like this in a more inclusive manner...regional politics, global politics etc..in all this we have to salute our Top Cops for doing a great job
Personal Political Vendetta
by Bindiya Shetty on 2008-12-01 22:19:34.510171+05:30
People with personal agendas and vendettas can't bear to see Honest, Police Officers who cannot be politically influenced. It would only be fitting to Sentence all arrested in Malegaon blasts and their aids to solitary imprisonment for the death of these officers. Also, we need to find out who issued the orders for these men to travel together. PERSONAL VENDETTA.
03 Top Police Officials Death,
by N K Rao on 2008-11-29 19:22:53.29607+05:30
The death of these 03 top officials is an irrepairable loss to the country
Death OF Top Police Officers
by agpathania on 2008-11-29 19:15:01.188678+05:30
May their soles rest in peace. But if the version of the injured Constable is correct and factual, then there have been grave mistakes on the part of these officers.1.When a situation like this is on, then on hearing that one of your officers is injured and in hospital, should not make senior Officers leave areas like CST where a major attack had taken place and rush to hospital. that too all bunched up in a Qualis!!!2. When ever such senior Officers travel the security should never be in the same vehicle as they are in. The security should have been in the only place from where they could have given security cover, that in a vehilce following behind. This is a simple and fundamental principle of security, which even a layman to security as me knows.3. It seems that perhaps they were not aware of the magnitude of the strike and were under the impression that this was some kind of GANG WAR!!!4. Whatever it was Ihope serious lessons have been drawn from this blunder. RIP.
mumbai terror
by ajay sadhwani on 2008-11-29 19:13:07.290101+05:30
The biggest problem is that we are reactive and not proactive. In future contingency plans will be made to prevent attacks of this nature from coming to fruition. However, the killers will have by then devised new strategies to succeed with their evil plans. We need younger, intelligent and smarter leaders to manage the nation.
A Quesdtion
by Ali on 2008-11-29 18:44:30.077384+05:30
Sir,Who was the main target of Mumbai attacks ? IS it the the ATS top brass , who were doing professionally investigation of the Malegaon blast. And to show that they were not the target many innocent peoples have to give their lives.
professional?
by Hems on 2008-11-29 22:40:51.329754+05:30
how do u know it was 'prefessional'? Do you mean 'profitable'?
Death of a hero
by margazhi mama on 2008-11-29 18:42:25.777011+05:30
It is too much of a concidence that 2 terrorist stepped out from behind a tree and the first (police) vehicle they tried to comandeer was that of the ATS chief. Link this with the fact that the terrs inside the Taj Hotel cheered when they heard of the death of Karkare. Who in the ATS was feeding info about their chief's movements to the terrs? What was the true message that was conveyed to Karkare to make him go from CST to Cama hospital?
death of top police officers
by Ehateshaam on 2008-11-29 17:52:32.173274+05:30
The death of ATS cheif Mr.Karkare along with other top police officers is a very sad thingThey were great people and very honest people.May GOD rest their soul in peace.We salute them for their bravery and their sacrifice for the nation!!!
saluting the officers...
by Pallavi on 2008-11-29 17:35:52.016215+05:30
How can people think such in dis time of adversity?Of course these officers r matyrs.they were on their way 2 meet a injured fellow officer,not for any recreation.In these times when we stood stand united
Mr. Karkare's death a mystery.
by Ray Kumar on 2008-11-29 16:57:07.089781+05:30
Mr. Karkare's death a mystery.As rightly said by Indian "third version of the story" we smell some fishy thing in the death of Mr. Karkare, vijay salaskar, Ashok Kamte and the three constables. The void created by them, I don't think will be filled. May their soul rest in peace and may Almighty give strength to their families to bear the loss. We are proud of you and we salute you all.
will we ever know the truth
by Bhanu Mehta on 2008-11-29 16:53:44.56795+05:30
The top officers were on way to Cama Hospital, just a 10-minute drive from CST station, to check on another injured officer Sadanand Date.I would have thought that when there is a serious crises top officers would rush to the place of crime and try to catch or kill terrorist and not rush to the hospital to see a injured police personal was is the chief of the aTS or the police welfare officer
Karkare - the true Indian........
by Asadulgaba on 2008-11-29 16:46:16.990748+05:30
This seems to be a totally different terrorist attack. It was only the favour of certain rightistelements to kill karkare. The terrorists running around Mumbai streets would impossibly plan, detect and kill karkare. "Kisine bahti ganga me hath dhoye hain".
