Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

Doctored?

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • Imagine the misfortune that befell Air India’s pilots. While they were reeling under the spectre of pay cuts, they were suffering from headaches, stomach ailments, migraine and toothaches. For that is what they have been claiming as reasons for going on “sick leave”, sickness that miraculously vanished when they finally called off their strike on Wednesday. This is a farce and everybody knows it. The pilots, spoilt and overpaid, had struck work in protest, not out of pain. Yet, they feigned illness to avoid the technical repercussions of being on strike; some have even produced doctors’ certificates. What does this say about the standards of our medical profession?

    A doctor who takes the Hippocratic Oath swears to “preserve the purity of my life and my arts”. The trust that is reposed in doctors’ certificates is based on the special place these “arts” hold in any society’s psyche. But at a time when false medical certificates are available for a fee, when doctors do not think twice before noting down an illness for a pleading patient, that trust is being called into question. Such brouhaha over a signed piece of paper might seem exaggerated. So what if somebody bunks a day of class or work? But the forged certificates end up hurting the genuinely ill who are looked upon with suspicion. Worse, they shine a harsh light on the noblest of professions and the body meant to regulate it.

    Ads by Google

    Tasked with maintaining standards of medical education, granting permission to new colleges, and recognising/ derecognising doctors, the Medical Council of India is a self-regulating body. Like the Bar Council of India and the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India, it is based on the assumption that the technical requirements of a profession are best understood by those professionals themselves. But there is a fine line between a self-regulator and a lobby. The Bar Council hardly ever punishes errant lawyers, nor does the Medical Council usually go after doctors who put their signature on false certificates. It is good that the Air India management has called the pilots’ bluff, asking them to report to the airline doctor for certification of their illness. But the matter goes beyond the management. The MCI must step in, and take to task those doctors, and all others, who leave their imprint on blatantly false medical certificates.

    New invention-headache detector?By: Jimmy | 03-Oct-2009 Reply | Forward Have they discovered a new "headache detector" device which can confirm whether a patient really has a headache?Till such time the doctor really has to rely on the patient, if the patient says she has an ailment.
    Management Versus LabourBy: P.N. Sarin | 02-Oct-2009 Reply | Forward Executive pilots are supposed to be part of management. Why did they go on strike? Why were they not consulted before the management took the decision to cut salaries, etc.? To whom is the management responsible? The government? The investors in the case of a private company? Are not the pilots, engineers, MBAs, techinicians, loaders and even passengers not investors? I think the time has come when the artificial distinction between management and labour should be obliterated. They are all partners in business. They play with public money. We must evolve a new system in which businesses are conducted for the common good of society. Think over it.
    Menace of corruptionBy: brbajaj | 02-Oct-2009 Reply | Forward Point well raised by the Editor. Corruption has been all prevasive and no profession how soever noble it might have been designated or pronounced had remained untouched. The regulating bodies of different professions have become mute spectators or corrupt themselves,so to define correctly.We cann't expect the Government to take a call, as it itself is deep rooted in corruption, courtsey the pitfalls of an election process and degradation of value system in the society.Still the call has to be taken. I think the people of this country from different walks of life have to take a lead and make a movement like the one we witnessed at the time of independence and this time it is liberation of society or the nation from the ill of corruption, which by no mean less important than the liberation of the country. I complement the Editor for raising a just and equitable voice on the issue.
    What ails AI?By: The All Knowing | 02-Oct-2009 Reply | Forward AI's ills can be cured only if it is allowed to breathe its last. As a PSU, it is beyond control. Its emp;oyees are callous and they treat their customers in a cavalier fashion. They don't care if the company makes a profit or not. They don't care if the customers they cater to are treated fairly or not. They know their jobs are safe, their salaries are underwritten by the government, and their benefits will only keep growing. It is high time to put this white elephant to sleep. India cannot afford such a luxury.
    GET GOING AS USUALBy: NITIN KUMAR | 02-Oct-2009 Reply | Forward There is nothing new if most of the striking executive pilots of Air India got false medical certificate to avoid stern action by Air India management.It is an age old practice that whenever sombody requires medical certificate for any type of excuse from their duty, he/she does not require to go far because it is available on almost every nook and coner of our country on throw away price.Medical profession is one of the noblest profession which requires highest level of morality,professional ethics and compassion nowadays bereft of such traits.When there are overall degadation in morality of society ,how we can expect medical profession will remain immune from such contagious phenomenon.Whether it is Indian Medicel Association ,Indian Bar Association or any other regulatory authority they are almost misnomer.Now question arises who are going to judge these judges.The technicalites are one thing and morality is another thing. So stern action and morality are two planks to act upon.
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.