Fear of cyber intrusion and control by China has prompted an inter-ministerial panel to recommend a complete ban on overseas sourcing of telecom equipment for all critical networks while supporting 100 per cent domestic sourcing for such projects.
Indias territorial boundaries are adjacent to unfriendly neighbours. If any critical network is built using equipment from hostile countries and the same is shut down for a small time period,the countrys security will be seriously compromised, says the report on Preference to Domestically Manufactured Electronic & Telecom Goods in Procurement,due to Security Considerations,and in Government Procurement. For this very reason,Japan,Taiwan and South Korea,who also are in close geographical proximity to hostile countries,do not allow any critical network to be built using equipment from such countries, says the July 19 report.
Among the projects identified for complete domestic sourcing are the national optic fibre network,network for spectrum and other defence communication networks,national knowledge network and all communication projects of all utility companies such as the Indian Railways,and oil,gas and power companies.
Since most of the products are already available in the country or can be developed in the required timelines,it must be ensured that 100 per cent of the requirement of critical equipment for such projects should be domestically manufactured at the earliest, the panel recommends.
However,to ensure that the preferential access to domestic firms does not violate WTO provisions,the notificationyet to be issued by the Telecom Ministryspecifies that preferential treatment would be given only for projects that have security implications for the country and in government purchases for own use and not with a view to commercial resale or with a view to use in the production of commercial goods for resale.
The panels comment shows the continued government skepticism on Chinese firms Huawei and ZTE that dominate Indias telecom sector. Law enforcement agencies have been warning about the rampant use of sophisticated equipment that could compromise the countrys security as the Chinese firms do not share technical information and ‘system keys of their products with Indian operators. For this,too,the committee suggests that the source code/IPR,knowhow and know-why of all products should be in India and be available to any government agency at any time. This is to ensure security as well as long-term support,maintenance and future upgrades, it adds.
Further,to ensure assured supplies at all times,the entire design,source code and manufacturing should be in India. Also,the product should not be subject to export control laws of any foreign country, says the report.
The reason for the panels concern is that critical projects require a secure backbone network that must be fully trusted at all times. The panels fear is that as use of telecom and information and communications technology becomes all pervasive,the ability to use these devices and applications to disrupt normal human life and threaten life and property by an inimical interest becomes increasingly common.
The existing preferential access policy mandates that both state-owned and private phone – mobile and landline – companies buy up to 30 per cent of network equipment and other related infrastructure from domestic manufacturers. The new policy wants these licensees to scale this up to a minimum of 80 per cent by 2020.