Finance minister Pranab Mukherjees plan to roll out a national level goods and services tax (GST) by April 1,2012,may get further delayed as finance ministers of two key states have said that it may not be possible. Citing a lack of consensus amongst political parties as well as loss of states autonomy,Madhya Pradesh finance minister Raghavji and Bihars deputy chief minister Sushil Modi on Tuesday said that the deadline would not be met.
Why will states agree to give up their fiscal autonomy when in effect they will turn into municipal corporations and keep begging for compensation from the Centre? The idea of GST is against the principles laid down in the Constitution as well. We have time and again expressed our reservations on the tax, Raghavji said on the sidelines of a seminar organised by the Comptroller and Auditor General of India.
Meanwhile,breaking away from the stand taken by BJP-ruled states,Modi called the tax a historic reform. If GST is implemented,Bihar will be a part of it. There is no question of having our own choice or dislike. This is a historic reform and we believe that the entire country should be part of this reform. It is also a part of the BJPs manifesto, he said,adding that though in the short run there may be some revenue losses,GST will help states in the long-term.
He,however,conceded that individual states have problems regarding the structure of GST,such as threshold,rate and compensation. It is not only BJP-ruled states but also others like Tamil Nadu and Uttar Pradesh that have expressed reservations, he said.
Flatly ruling out the introduction of the tax from the new date of April 1,2012,Modi said,It is not possible. Apart from the long drawn process for amending the Constitution,there is no consensus on the political front, he pointed out.
However,both Modi and Raghavji said that the tax reform has not been put on the backburner though the empowered committee of state finance ministers is currently headless after its former chairman and West Bengal finance minister Asim Dasgupta lost the assembly elections.
The people of Bihar had given us a mandate. I would not be able to do justice (by serving both posts). When Pranab Mukherjee telephoned,after consulting my colleagues,I refused. I told him that I would cooperate with anybody who become the chairman of the Empowered Committee, Modi said while commenting on his refusal to head the Empowered Committee. Raghavji said Modis decision was a personal one and it was not a party stand to decline the offer. It was left to Sushil Modi himself, Raghavji,who is also a senior BJP leader,said.
The Congress-led states,meanwhile,seem to be ready to embrace the GST. Yes,we are ready (for the GST), Kerala finance minister K M Mani said.