Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

Haryana panchayat takes on govt over same-gotra marriage

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • As the 72-hour deadline given to 23-year-old Ravinder Gehlawat’s family to leave Dhrana village in Jhajjar district expired on Sunday morning, tension gripped the area after angry villagers threw stones when the police stopped them from accosting the family. As many as 500 policemen have been stationed in the village after the incident.

    This isn’t the first time that the same-gotra marriage dispute has come to the fore in Haryana. But this is a rare occasion when the collective panchayat (known as khap) is in direct confrontation with not only with the boy’s family but also with the administration.

    Earlier last week, Ravinder’s entire clan was told to leave their native village of Dhrana, as their son had married 20-year-old Shilpa Kadiyan of Siwah village near Panipat. He was accused of violating a custom which the panchayat feels is sacrosanct, i.e. there can be no matrimony between the sects of Gehlawat and Kadiyan as they have a “brotherhood” akin to consanguinity. The Gehlawat family was given an ultimatum to leave the village, bag and baggage, within 72 hours. There is a penalty of Rs 21,000 on any other villager who dares to talk or help them in any manner.

    Ads by Google

    Rohtas Singh, father of Ravinder, says, “We had decided to leave on Friday. But then I got a call from Ravinder who asked us to wait for two hours. He drove all the way back from Delhi where he works as a driver with a call centre. When he reached here, he told us that he had consumed camphor tablets to save us from misery. As of now, he is struggling with his life.” The condition of Ravinder, admitted to the main hospital in Rohtak, is described as stable, but doctors have kept him under observation for 72 hours.

    ... contd.

    Next123
    panchyata is not a god and judge By: kamaldulgach | 24-Nov-2009 Reply | Forward all are the humen are brother and sister form panchayata side why do marry with a gril with a boy sciecne said cosin is the sister of blood all huaman blood is the same in this world so how can be sister and brother as the same gotra coples nature cant demand this thing why are the human demad allthis rubbies things time of the born not a kids get with his or her gotra if all are the humen in blood relation sister and brothers then why dont stop the marreige system in the world what is the tradition becouse love is the great then the tradition the tradition has divide the people in world love is the brig close the people together love is the first thing in this world then why dont give the people prefrence to the love becouse people not care of the social value who is in the love and panchyta is not a god ad judge in other life law is the first thins in this coutry there is no writing in hindu sastra about the gotra no given valu in any granth geeta kuran ramayan mahabhart then why
    Scientific traditionBy: Ravi Chaudhary | 09-Aug-2009 Reply | Forward To be a little more rational, societies have norms.The Vedic, Hindu norm is to avoid same goth, (Gothra marriage), 1st cousin marriage etc to keep diversity in the breeding pool. This is an ancient custom.One might also compliment our ancestors, who developed this scientific system.The society should also respect the local traditional customs. Local customs in North India, support the ancient Vedic custom. Not only is same Goth( clan lineage) forbidden , but also marriage in neighbouring villages.There is much scientific basis for this, and readers are welcome to explore the net for that. There are plenty of references.That is the basis behind the Hindu marriage act.In the recent controversy, the Court is misinpterpreting the letter and spirit of the act, by permiting same goth(ra) marriage.What is the point of having a Hindu Marriage Act, if all forms of marriage relationships are allowed???.Now if people wish to change the rules, so be it- allow first cousin
    who cares gotra while they falling in loveBy: riken mane | 27-Jul-2009 Reply | Forward i thing the power of love is greater than gotra.if someone fall in love he or she they are not think that which gotra they are belong from forthfather goverment should take some action against this kind of crises.its dosent matter any men or women belongs from which gotra if those familys are diffrent then they dont want to think about teh communiti.if we crosscheckd all marriages then i am sure we will find somethig disaster....are you agree panchayat so did you have any answer of this question?if no so for god say dont invold in such kind of relationships.because some relations are god gifted nobody will can't change.such think your did it's so uncool.after all love is feeling also the god gifted so please try to change this kind of customs.otherwise what will happen after some years you can't get even single girl or boy to get marry whith your people..........just think about it please once.....al goverment has to take some action against this kind of problems.....................?
    Same Gotra marriageBy: Vivek Sahajpal | 25-Jul-2009 Reply | Forward The Panchayats decision is correct. Hindu marriage should be according to the Laws of Manu. Same gotra means a common forefather and hence same gotra people are like brothers and sisters. This is scientifically correct and checks inbreeding. This is why the Hindu poplation has remained so vibrant. Four gotras are to avoided according to the Hindu marriage tradition. I salute to the Panchayat that has stood up against the administration. Same gotra marriage is "GRAVE SIN". There should be changes in the marriage act and it should ban same gotra marriage for Hindus. This is must to save our tradition. Moreover this has scientific basis. But I have one complaint about the panchayats and the Parents i.e they donot teach these values at a young age to their kids. That’s why such problems occur. Children should be made aware of traditions before they grow up. Today I have seen may young men and women don't know what there gotra is! Parents are responsible for this ignorance
    GOTRA AND THE PANCHAYATBy: NIRANJAN | 20-Jul-2009 Reply | Forward FIRST OF ALL IN THE OLDEN DAYS, WHEN THE POPULAION WAS SCANT, MARRYING WITHIN A CIRCLE OF GOTRA WAS TABU. IN THOSE DAYS THE ANCESTRY WOULD COINCIDE IN 2-3 GENERATIONS. NOW, WITH THE POPULATION OF A GOTRA BEING SO LARGE, THE ANCESTRY WILL ONLY COINCIDE SAY 20 GENERATIONS AGO. IF WE HAVE THIS KIND OF RESTRICTIONS ON MARRIAGE ALL OF US WOULD BE BROTHER OR A SISTER OT SOMEONE MAY BE 100 GENERATIONS AGO. ALSO, PANCHAYAT CARRYING SUCH POWER IS DISTURBING. LET'S TRY TO GET EDUCATED AND MODERN PEOPLE IN PANCHAYATs INSTEAD OF OLD GEEZERS WHO THINK THEY KNOW EVERYTHING AND DON'T WANT TO CHANGE WITH TIMES.
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.