You are here: IE »   Story

Healthcare’s grand reformation

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • Discount UK Shopping
    I believe that India will become the first country in the world to dissociate healthcare from affluence. In our lifetime we will see millions of people, still perhaps living in slums with no running water or sanitation, but when they are unwell, they will have access to high-tech healthcare with dignity, like in the developed world. There will be a gross disconnect between the place they live and the quality of healthcare they will receive. This can only happen in India. It cannot happen in China despite their bigger economy. I say this with conviction since we produce the largest number of doctors, nurses and medical technicians in the world. Outside the US, we have the largest number of USFDA-approved drug manufacturing units. We have all it takes to emerge as the largest and the best healthcare providers in the world in a short period, provided we enforce some regulatory reform to address the delivery system.

    Ads by Google

    First and foremost, the government should become a health insurance provider than a healthcare provider. Can the government run a software company or a hotel? They can’t: these are complicated businesses. Believe me, healthcare is a hundred times more complicated than these businesses. When we suggest that the government should become a health insurance provider, we are not talking about Mediclaim type of insurances with Rs. 2,000/- premium. We are talking about health insurance where the premium is 5-10 rupees per month. Six years ago when we launched a now well-known programme, called Yeshaswini micro-health insurance, with a premium of five rupees per month, everyone laughed at us. Today we have 3 million farmers subscribing to the scheme by paying five rupees per month, and the scheme has been adopted all across the state. Andhra Pradesh changed the model slightly with the government paying the entire premium for the BPL cardholders. We are opposed to the idea of poor people not paying anything. We want them to contribute a tiny amount of money in installments. But for this to happen, the government should create a vehicle for people to pay a small amount whenever they can.

    The government should not try to make money at the cost of people’s health. Today when you pop a pill or you get a heart operation done, nearly 20-25 per cent of the money goes to the government. Technically speaking, when more people fall sick in India, the government earns more money. For the next ten years if the government comes up with a policy so that it doesn’t earn money from the miseries of people who are hospitalised or unwell, healthcare costs can go down significantly.

    Without large investment in the healthcare industry, it will remain a mom and pop operation. The largest corporate chain of hospitals in India has a revenue of just 800 crores — in fact, some Maruti spare parts dealers have higher revenues. If the economy of scale is to reduce healthcare costs, the industry has to grow hugely. For this, the government must give the healthcare industry infrastructure status so that, like others, it can borrow at low rates and repay over a 10-20 years period. Tax holidays, which are given for hospitals in non-metros and outskirts of the city should be extended to every new hospital all across the country.

    There are many international agencies which fund large healthcare projects provided these projects are backed by sovereign guarantees. The government could guarantee this programme, since in case of default, they have the large assets created by these hospitals. Sovereign guarantee loans come with a very low interest and the repayment period is over 10 years. Currently only government hospitals enjoy this line of credit. This should be extended to large-scale projects with over 2000 beds. Major reforms are required in medical education. Currently, our medical education system allows less than 10 per cent of the graduating doctors to become specialists. Even though we produce one of the largest number of doctors in the world, a very small fraction of them become medical specialists, which is going to be a major problem in the near future. We need to create thousands of training positions for surgeons, physicians, diabetologists, nephrologists etc. Major tax incentives should be given to industrial houses to set up large-scale hospitals in the Northeast, where the political situation makes it difficult for investment to change the healthcare dynamics in the region.

    If the last century was driven by machines which address human toil, the healthcare industry will drive the economy in our time. Today healthcare is the rare industry that generates employment in America. For a turnover of a quarter of million dollars they barely require five to seven people, whereas for the same quantum of revenue in our industry, we need to hire 250 people. Our workers are semi-skilled and unskilled people; most of them are nursing staff. They have no options but to work in India, given their skill levels. In terms of job creation, our policymakers must look at healthcare as an industry which is going to contribute significantly in the area of equitable growth by creating millions and millions of jobs.

    The writer is a cardiac surgeon and has designed Karnataka’s low-cost health insurance scheme, ‘Yeshaswini’.

    Healthcare's Grand ReformationBy: Dr S Datta | 16-Jun-2009 Reply | Forward While I agree with Dr Devi Shetty's views, an area crying out for reform is Medical education, without which his ideas are unlikely to succeed. We need mass produced basic doctors (and I'm not talking about un/ under qualified 'barefoot doctors'!)who can expertly save life and limb and treat the common disorders that account for 95% of human healthcare issues. Unfortunately, our current medical curriculum has not evolved to the requirements of our country's needs; we seem to be better equipped to produce hi-tech, 'academic'doctors suitable for the needs of the the more prosperous urban Indians and the Western world. While I don't deny the requirement of such doctors in our country, I feel that the mass produced 'basic doctor'is a greater necessity...
    helthcare grandBy: keshav | 16-Jun-2009 Reply | Forward sir, you very righly deffered the types of business our goverment. although healthcare sector is fragile in rural areas, i completely agrtee with yours view that indian can change these figures in next decade. only one thing our goverment lacks is the copycat coordination policies, when one state does a program succesfully , why cant others states apply it homeheartedly????
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.