Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

Here we go again?

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • Arunachal Pradesh has a tradition of high voter turnouts, and Tuesday was no different. But as 72 per cent of the electorate showed up at polling booths to elect a new state assembly, Beijing appeared to strike a discordant note by objecting to the prime minister’s visit to the state 10 days ago as part of an election campaign schedule. The foreign ministry in New Delhi duly filed its “disappointment and concern”. Away from the irony of China emphasising the “disputed” status of Arunachal on the day its people cast their vote in large numbers, the incident serves as a reminder of what is becoming all-too-familiar a pattern. And it is not just that China is using every forum (the Asian Development Bank, for instance) and every cue (the prime minister’s visit) to underline its official position on the status of Arunachal. It is that India must factor into its China strategy an expectation of such posturing.

    This expectation has two dimensions. One, as the rolling hysteria over Chinese “incursions” in sections of the media last month showed, the government needs to be far more attentive to spin and information dispersal. Then, it took a statement by the prime minister to give enough weight to clarifications from the national security advisor, the foreign secretary and the army chief that aimed to scotch the scare-mongering. That extraordinary effort will remain an act of expedient fire-fighting if it is not followed up with a cohesive attempt to beget wider public understanding of the complexities of vast stretches of India’s borders. The “dispute” on the border with China has a long history of one-two steps by Beijing to keep the border unsettled, and not necessarily to signal a declaration of hostilities. In addition, after the protests in Tibet before last year’s Beijing Olympics and the subsequent tension in Xinjiang, China’s statements are also seen to be informed by a domestic anxiety. However, a rationalisation of such behaviour does not imply business as usual. It calls for a far greater measure of diplomatic agility in shaving the spin and hysteria off the news headlines than New Delhi has so far shown. Else, as with the public statement by its spokesperson on Tuesday, Beijing will continue to flaunt its confidence in setting the tone on the border dispute.

    ... contd.

    Next12
    Kolkata to London and Darjeeling to Switzerland-latest jokes.By: Ashok Ghosh | 17-Oct-2009 Reply | Forward Politicians in India are mostly governed by short sighted vision and unattainable missions. Our Budgets hardly explain the reasons for failure.By that they gain disrespect and assume the people as ignorant/fool.Thanks to failure of Literacy program otherwise they would have failed. Peoples have to sacrifice to keep alive the politicians offices.Is there any punishment for such declarations which are not attainable atleast during the period for which they seek peoples mandate?
    Chinese DragonBy: P.H.Bhanage | 16-Oct-2009 Reply | Forward Mr. Shekhar Gupta seems to have more faith in chinese than chinese themselves.Refusing to keep our eyes open to stark realities of our past as far as China is concerned,will be detrimental to the security of India.Jawaharlal Nehru has led country to the disaster of 1962 by his daydreaming.IE is repeating the same terrible mistake.Those who caution the Govt.,people of India about the dangers lurking from our North East are branded as war mongers.One thing is very clear;China does not want INDIA to prosper hence would do everything possible to instigate our hostile neighbores to keep fomenting the tensions on our borders.Mr. Nitin Mathur(the writer on this blog)appears to have great faith in Communist Comrades like Somanath Chatterji.I wish to remind him that our friends,particularly from the CPM had refused to acknowledge that the China had committed aggression in 1962.They were toeing the Chinese Govt. line.Their solution to the present problem could be to give away A'chal.Pr.to China.
    Defence preparationBy: Reeta | 15-Oct-2009 Reply | Forward How about simply raising our defence budget to 4% of GDP, putting infrastructure development at AP of fast track, show some urgency in buying new artillery guns (havn't purchased new ones from last 25 years)and again decide on MRCA fast.India also needs to raise 5 new mountain divisions instead of just 2 new which India is doing right now.
    Typical Indian HypocricyBy: Pradip | 15-Oct-2009 Reply | Forward u guys dont c buffalo lurking in ur body, but scream to see an ant on others body. U r crying as if Chinese are pointing guns on your right side of the head. Why is their no subjective analysis? Why this hysteria? I think this is the reason why every neighbors (except for obedient Bhutan) hate India. Chinese r right to say that if war ever happen, it will happen because of India's behaviour.
    Foreign Ministry, IFS and NSABy: nitin mathur | 15-Oct-2009 Reply | Forward There are few observations which need a reflection. From 1948 onward China has been using all opportunities to cut India to size. Be it UNSC, annexation of Tibet, sabotaging the Panchsheel declaration, invasion in 1962, role in 1971 war, continuous control in PoK and Korakoram Range, issues on Sikkim, intrusion in AP, blocking India's membership in Economic forum in Asia-Pacific regions, ADB Aid, Nuclear Passage bills, etc. We need to reflect: 1) Do we have sufficient bureaucrats who can match the China advances from Military, Diplomatic as well as Economic side.2) Can these three teams work cohesively.3)Do they need inputs from Defence forces, NSA and IB.4) Is Home Ministry also required to be part of the larger team.5) Can we seek services of good Parliamentarians like Somnath Chatterjee (even when he is not from Cong)or well read Jaipal Reddy or retd. IFS bureaucrats and NSA advisors like Brajesh Mishra for a cause against the Chinese Dragon.
    How one can shame shameless ?By: YD | 16-Oct-2009 Reply | Forward The biggest draw back and impediment in India's growth are corrupt bureaucrats and politicians, mainly Congress. When politicians and bureaucrats do not have shame how one can shame them ? Point to consider is do these politicians and bureaucrats consider themselves as Indians or foreign rulers ?
    shame shamelessBy: Ashok Ghosh | 17-Oct-2009 Reply | Forward on 16 Oct last Kolkattans have witnessed a further rape on democracy which was initiaited by politicians, seen by bureaucrats, projected by media in the manner desired, world at large laughed at and people had to suffer.Politicians represent insignificant part of society and their followers are nominal compared to population of the state.Why not HC initiate a PIL against loss of mandays and sufferings? Union govt should react insuch a situation as image of the country is tarnished. of total
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.