Premium
This is an archive article published on April 8, 2009

Holbrooke,Mullen meet Narayanan

US envoy Richard Holbrooke,accompanied by Chairman of US Joint Chiefs of Staff Admiral Mike Mullen,met Indian officials on Wednesday amid concern in New Delhi that Washington's new regional strategy for Afghanistan is pandering to its old foe Pakistan.

US special envoy Richard Holbrooke on Wednesday met National Security Adviser M K Narayanan and is understood to have discussed how India could help Washington’s strategy aimed at ending terror threats emanating from Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Holbrooke,the special envoy for Afghanistan and Pakistan,was accompanied by Chairman of US Joint Chiefs of Staff Admiral Mike Mullen.

Holbrooke is also meeting Foreign Secretary Shivshankar Menon.

Holbrooke is believed to have discussed ways in which New Delhi could cooperate in US efforts to “defeat” terrorism originating from Pakistan and Afghanistan.

The two top US officials arrived here late last night after a visit to Pakistan,where Holbrooke underlines that economic and military aid provided by the US would be linked to Islamabad’s concrete support to war against Al-Qaida.

The US has sought to link its strategy in Afghanistan and Pakistan for resumption of Indo-Pak dialogue. Washington argues that resumption of the dialogue would ease pressure on Islamabad and allow it to help America in the war in Afghanistan.

India maintains that the US needs to focus on targeting terror bases in Pakistan if the scourge is to be rooted out.

It also believes that Islamabad is lacking capability or will to target terror bases in Pakistan and hence the international needs to act collectively and assertively.

Unease in Indo-US relations

Story continues below this ad

US envoy Richard Holbrooke will meet Indian officials on Wednesday amid concern in New Delhi that Washington’s new regional strategy for Afghanistan is pandering to its old foe Pakistan.

The trip by Holbrooke,special envoy to Afghanistan and Pakistan,is his first to India since President Barack Obama announced plans to boost troop numbers in Afghanistan,while helping Pakistan with more military and non-military aid.

Holbrooke,along with Admiral Mike Mullen,chairman of the US Joint Chiefs of Staff,will meet Foreign Secretary Shivshankar Menon on Wednesday.

India is uneasy that Obama’s strategy fails to reflect its concerns about what New Delhi sees as Pakistan’s backing of militants,analysts and government officials say.

Story continues below this ad

There are also concerns that Pakistan wants a solution to disputed Kashmir as an element of any regional peace efforts,a condition that India rejects.

“They think if a dialogue begins,that itself will be a move forward,” an Indian government official said. “But this will only be a listening brief for us. We really aren’t interested unless our concerns are addressed.”

Many Indian analysts and officials worry Washington is biased toward helping Pakistan — an old US ally — rather than India,which only in recent years moved closer to the United States.

“The US is more receptive to Pakistan’s concerns,which is worrying India,” said Bharat Karnad of the Centre for Policy Research,a New Delhi-based independent strategic think-tank.

Story continues below this ad

The presence of India in Afghanistan,where it is spending millions of dollars in infrastructure projects,worries Pakistan.

“The US has bought the Pakistan military’s line that India’s presence in Afghanistan is a threat to them,” former Indian foreign secretary Kanwal Sibal said.

“And they are saying if the US wants Pakistan’s full cooperation in fighting al Qaeda,then something should be done to contain or limit India’s presence.”

Holbrooke on Tuesday denied Washington wanted to become a mediator between the two neighbours. “That is not our job,” he told reporters in Islamabad before going to India. Asked about the Kashmir dispute being part of his remit,he said: “That was a misunderstanding. I’m not going to be involved in it.”

INDIAN SENSITIVITIES

Story continues below this ad

Holbrooke’s visit comes weeks before a general election and the government is not expected to make any commitments.

“So why is he coming now? Because the Americans want to engage India,draw them into the sphere on Afghanistan.” an Indian government official said. “They are pushing for a dialogue between India and Pakistan because that is imperative for the American strategy for Afghanistan.”

India does not want to talk to Pakistan unless Islamabad investigates the planners of last November’s attacks on Mumbai that killed 166 people,prompting New Delhi to put a four-year-old peace initiative on hold.

Pakistan was the Taliban’s main backer until Islamabad publicly sided with Washington after the Sept. 11,2001,attacks. India accuses it of giving covert support to Islamist forces which bombed the Indian embassy in Kabul last year.

Story continues below this ad

Pakistan says India is arming its Baluch rebels and using Indian consulates in Afghanistan for anti-Pakistan activities.

Stay updated with the latest - Click here to follow us on Instagram

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Loading Taboola...
Advertisement