Murderous union
by john jacobs on 2008-09-24 08:50:31.930798+05:30
Oscar Fernandes' statement that the murder of L. K Chaudhary should serve as a warning to employers who are reluctant to yield to union demands, seem to condone and justify his killing at the hands of an unruly union.His statement is most unbecoming of a Union Minister and the least the Center could do to inject some semblance of civility is to sack this man immediately from office. The brutal murder of the C.E.O and the subsequent approving nature shown by the minister could happen only in a savage, lawless and uncivilised country.
Re: Govt says Noida CEO death a warning, India Inc in shock
by Dr. Nikhil Joshi on 2008-09-24 08:08:55.838771+05:30
Is it shameful to see a Government encouraging vigilante justice. This means that taking law in own hands is allowed and also that sacking is justification for murder.
Warning Indeed!!
by harkol on 2008-09-24 08:02:11.501837+05:30
Warning for the Management???Workers to be dealt with Compassion???Oscar Fernandis has lost it!!! These are workers from Hell. Criminals who don't hesitate to murder. You think any company would want them??This is a warning to All of India. If we do not change our laws, and control our Labour unions, the business houses will either leave the country or will be forced to resort to hiring mafia to protect themselves. If Unions think they can murder, it is just time before Businesses factor that into their equation of doing business in India.Oscar Fernandis has completely misread this. The warning is not to managements. It is to government!!
Killing of CEO
by Suren on 2008-09-24 07:54:04.7372+05:30
It is a shame that the minister is justifying a lynching by stating that "workers should be dealt with compassion". No one should be allowed to take the law into their own hands. If managements decide to employ goons to break up worker protests would the minister be so "understanding". He is just trying to garner votes and nothing else.
This is what you get when you vote for Congress
by Shantanu Soman on 2008-09-24 07:00:03.009791+05:30
This is what you get when you vote for Congress
Oscar and competency?
by Anupam Gupta on 2008-09-24 06:43:12.574569+05:30
"The situation had been repeatedly brought to the attention of the competent Indian authorities, both at central and local level," the Italian Embassy said in a statement. Only if the Italians knew that "Oscar Fernandes's competence limits to keeping Sonia Maiono gandhi happy"! and they must have realized now that there is nothing like "competent" athority in India under Italian "Raj"
shameful minister
by Rohit on 2008-09-24 06:26:52.230645+05:30
Minister Please put youer head in a bucket of water and die
Noida CEO death
by Narayanan on 2008-09-24 06:09:35.561676+05:30
This will serve as warning to politicians. The day is not far off of when many will get lynched by public for being very apathetic to the condition of common man.

CEO's Murder
by Ashok Mehdiratta on 2008-09-24 05:20:28.505725+05:30
This is a clear case of murder,wherein Company's MD has been a victim of workers Goonda Gardi.I thought that only Left supported Unions do this but UP politics has been worse.Without instigation from a local mafia Don,this action could not have been contemplated.Union Labour Minister's statements,to say the least, are deplorable.We have another George Fernandes in the making.Work to rule culture has to be curbed.We have whole lot of commies to retard the progress of our country and now Congress is behaving in a idiotic manner.Physical assaults,damage to property,work to rule will naver bring in harmonious relation.Similarly dictatorship,theoretical HR knowledge,companies hiring fresh recruits from M-schools and greed for windfall profit are the main reasons for labour unrest.Youngsters have no loyalty to the companies,they quit as soon as they see a slight greener pasture.There is a need to have experienced HR managers.In this respect retired Army officers are the best bet .
Killing of the CEO
by Anand on 2008-09-24 05:04:44.43054+05:30
How hopeless are the ministers comments. Is he condoning the killing ?Does he mean to say that if someone is going to take away your job... kill him ?
Killing of NOIDA CEO
by Moses on 2008-09-24 01:57:48.532265+05:30
It appears Oscar is blaming the management and condoning the lynching! Who will invest in India if CEO's of multi-national get lynched? Oscar join the Maoist Party! Thats where you belong with that attitude.
red band chage ur mind set
by koiro on 2008-09-24 01:50:47.911269+05:30
it is indeed a shocking incident. This incident will showcase the detiorating law
Lynching of CEO
by Hemant on 2008-09-24 00:14:31.884266+05:30
I am confused. Is minister justifying killing?. From story it seem he is. This is unfortunate minister says " workers should be dealt with compassion" how about some discipline from workers. In any case killing someone can't be justified and Minister should not even try or hint at that, then it is UPA gov all ministers are irresponsible.Hemant
(mal) functioning brain
by Mash on 2008-09-24 00:12:43.253957+05:30
Is this guy insane? A law abiding (let us assume ) and a tax paying (atleast on salary that he received) was killed (literally) by unlawful behaviour. What is government implying "breaking law is O.K" if one discontented. Can I collect people and go out and kill. A ministry with a retrded brain; that;s why we have seen the most incompetent adminstration in recent years.. It seems we are getting functionally literate and mentally retarded people into executive and parliament,. Shame on You.
What face of India?
by Narula on 2008-09-24 00:10:24.974125+05:30
An irresponsible statement by the Minister. He doesn't condemn the mob violence and gives excuses for the murder. Basically giving the ok for mob rule.
bodyguards of Indira Gandhi were also discontent,
by we on 2008-09-23 23:58:22.820077+05:30
I and more that half a billion Indians are discontent with you Oscar, with all congress leadership, what should we do with you? I think bodyguards of Indira Gandhi were also discontent, Nalini was also discontent with Rajiv Gandhi. What do you say Mr. Oscar? Any wisdom probably from your clerical past?
Is this responsible answer?
by Snehal on 2008-09-23 23:33:12.377938+05:30
How can a government that bolster's claim to be for "aam aadmi" ignore a fact that aam aadmi needs "roti" and to earn that development. If it doesn't support industry how will it fulfill it's promise?!
US
by laadlabakdaas on 2008-09-23 23:10:03.310794+05:30
criminals don't deserve compassion. all the workers involved must be handed a strict punishment.
Govt says NOIDA CEO death a warning
by G Krishnamurthy on 2008-09-23 22:45:42.63811+05:30
The statement made by the Minister of Labour defies comment. It violates all norms of decency and is in despicable taste. It raises the question as to whether the Miinister concerned was in his senses when making this statement.
Brainless minister
by reddy on 2008-09-23 22:31:41.28284+05:30
Ministers response is disgusting. If lynching the way to express resentment ,Then God save India ! .Anyway what is this man proposing ? Lynch employers if you have disputes. Has this poor CEO made such a big mistake ,requiring death sentence by lynching ?Mr fernandez just swap your son or daughter with the CEO (who was killed)--I bet ,you would not be making such useless comments. God bless this man soul