Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

Lest IITs go the Air India way

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • The Indian Institutes of Technology ( IITs) are undoubtedly crown jewels in India’s system of higher education. Their contribution to making India largely self-reliant in top-notch manpower needs in diverse areas of engineering in the pre-liberalisation era, and to India’s emergence as a powerhouse in the knowledge economy in the era of liberalisation and globalisation is uncontestable. Even IITians who went abroad in large numbers have served the motherland in their own ways by achieving excellence in their professions and thus enhancing India’s prestige globally.

    With India beginning to offer better opportunities than before for the flowering of their talent, many of them are either returning home or supporting technology-driven ventures here, thus transforming “brain drain” into “brain gain”. True, IITs have many shortcomings. But none can deny their potential to address unmet expectations and to make India more proud. Which is why, there is a clamor for more of them to be set up. And the UPA government deserves kudos for its decision to establish nine new IITs, adding to the earlier bouquet of seven.

    Ads by Google

    Given the enormous prestige they enjoy, it was disconcerting to know that over 1,500 IIT teachers went on a one-day hunger strike last week. As an alumnus of IIT Bombay, I was both puzzled and perturbed by their unprecedented protest action. However, after speaking to several retired and current professors, I am convinced that the teachers’ case is more than half justified.

    Two sets of issues are agitating the IIT faculty. One is related to the pay of new entrants. Contrary to public perception, IIT teachers are not very highly paid. The starting salary of an assistant professor with a PhD is a mere

    ... contd.

    Next1234
    Proud IIT-Bombay AlumniBy: Hemendra Godbole | 09-Oct-2009 Reply | Forward While the issues driving a long-term resolution to attract and retain top-notch faculty are daunting, it is truly dis-heartening to read about the potential erosion of a brand we have all worked so hard to build. In a globalized world, sentiments like "NRIs have deserted us" are too pathetic to even discuss as relevant to the issues of attracting the best faculty. The FAN initiative by IIT-Bombay is a refreshing effort that has yielded results. As always, how specifically can the alumni help?To borrow a quote from the movie "Gladiator" -"The time for half measures and talk is over. Senator"
    One fails to understand why the government is trying to impose a failed modelBy: mittal | 28-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward Kudos to Mr Kulkarni for a well researched article on the IIT system. Till date IITs enjoyed relatively high autonomy as comapred to other education system in India. Let us consider the case of UGC system. Fate of the one time great universities like Allahabad, Bombay, and Madras etc voluminously speaks how the decades of strict governmental controls have brought these places of high learning to this sorry state. Probably, without looking at other sectors like Air India, we have examples within the education system itself. One fails to understand why the government is trying to impose a failed model on, one of the few Indian successful systems.Abscence of educationists from the helm of affairs in the Shastri Bhawan reinforces ones belief when author writes,"bureaucrats in New Delhi, with some good exceptions, think that they know everything and should control everything". It is not a case of business as usual. It needs to be seriously debated. Society too has a right to set goals.
    Salary of IIT faculties should be at par with other national institutesBy: Jay | 28-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward Faculties of IITs should get salaries at par other national institutes. But so far attracting bright, talented students is concerned, much more need to be done. Traditionally IITs give emphasis to teaching. Only teaching will never attract bright students who can think out-of-box, enjoy creativity and originality. Good teaching has to be supplemented and sustained by original research. IIT management must give more importance to research and evaluate young faculties more on the basis of what they achieve in terms of original research. Now they are evaluated on teaching basis. IITs also should give much more importance to biotechnology research (both medical and plant). I agree that IIT teachers need a decent salary to have a decent life (in a metro city) and so that they can concentrate more on research and teaching.
    SuggestionBy: Nash | 28-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward HRD Minister is right in saying that IIT lacks research excellence and technological innovation. It is true. So far IITs cater the needs of MNC and western countries. (in past India had been denied US technologies developed by NRI). But, what Minister is not realising that unless burden of undergraduate teachings are reduced, they do not have sufficient time to conduct research. Like IISc, IITs should only concentrate in Post Graduate Teaching and hence, they will have ample time to conduct research. In the process, excellence will be achieved. So, I have following suggestions: a)Autonomy must be given in faculty selection, framing rules, etc. to all IITs and IISc. b) IITs should be made for Post Graduate teaching (including Integrated PhD etc) and Research. c) NITs are for undergraduate teaching. d)IITs/IISc should get 20-30% more Salary than their counter parts in NIT. However, in NIT, who have research excellence in the level of IIT/IISc, may be given grade of IIT/IISc salary.
    ResearchBy: Dr Hanni V Doctor | 30-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward IIT is one of the best institute in research. Being an ex-IITian, experince, teaching and training at IIT has guided me in developing World Class technologies like Crude Oil Quality Improvement. Where heavily funded uuniversities in USA are lagging behind. IIT is a teching and research institute and it needs good fundings. Our politicians and ministers, irrespective of any political parties are interested in making money and vote banks by building unneccesary heavily funded infrastructures like four lane and eight lane higways where you hardly see a single wehicle for miles and miles, but are not interested in attracting GOOD talents at institute like IIT's and funding of projects which are beneficial to Nation INDIA. It is unfaortunate that all fundings are based on VOTE Banks and personal gaims and not for our country. If literacy increases, this bank will file Chapter 11 next day.
    IITs and their graduates and teachersBy: Dr. D. Prithipaul | 28-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward It has become a habit to eulogise the highly qualified scholars who go abroad to enhance the prosperity of their host countries. The question is: what difference is there, in principle, between these servants of foreign powers and the Gurkhas who exhausted their ammunition in firing at the crowd of their fellow citizens at the Jalianwalla Bagh? Are not the NRIs who "do honour to the mother country" as much, if not more, in being mercenaries as were the Gurkhas in the paid service of a foreign power? Is this question too harsh? If not, why is it not debated? What national pride can there be in the adoration of the NRI mercenaries who earn the praise of the likes of S. Kulkarni, when there is so much still waiting to be done in favour of those who still wallow in the degrading deficiency of those indispensable needs for leading a life of dignity and economic security? More: are not the anglophone NRIs the Trojan Horse which has enabled India to become an extension of Greater America?
    NRIs have stood by their country and it is ungrateful to forget their contribution By: Dr.G.Srinivasan | 28-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward NRIs were the peole who stood by India during the oil crisi of the 70's 90's and 90's .The so called patriots in side India just used them and are ungrateful
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.