Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

Moonshine for water

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • Last week as I watched Indian scientists crow with glee over having found ‘water on the moon’ and TV anchors burst with unconcealed pride, my own reaction was one of disbelief. In this moment of resurgent national pride, I hate to play spoilsport but it’s hard not to notice the surreal quality of our latest ‘achievement’. Dwell on it for a moment and you will see the absurdity of finding water on the moon when we have found it so hard to find adequate quantities of this vital beverage on Earth. If our scientists are so clever that they have been the first to find water on the moon, why is it so hard for them to help us find enough here in our land of depleted water resources and dying aquifers?

    The news of our latest national triumph came on the day that I landed in Mumbai after a 16-hour flight from New York. And, I could not help but think of the vast stretch of squalid shanties that I had driven past on my way into the city. I could not help remembering that in these unsanitary habitations not a single child has access to clean water. Many die before they reach the age of five on account of the filthy water on which they are bred.

    Ads by Google

    The real horror is that living standards in Mumbai’s shanties are better than they are in rural India. In our villages the chances of a child surviving till its fifth birthday are bleak. This is because standards of rural healthcare are abysmal and mothers are often illiterate and incapable of understanding the simple measures that would save a child’s life. One of the primary reasons for female illiteracy is that rural Indian women spend many hours in the day finding water for the family. Usually they walk miles and miles to find it.

    ... contd.

    Next123
    Hoping that Tavleen will see this and possibly mention it in her articleBy: Ritu | 29-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward Nice article, Tavleen. There's another important social issue that I fear no one is paying attention to while the IIT faculty's standoff with MHRD is big news.I happened to see one of the upcoming science institutes in Pune (IISER Pune), whose student's hostel was recently built and being occupied by the elite kids who cleared IIT JEE. The hostel by all means seems to be a great place with good facilities and the rest of the campus will follow soon.However, the laborers who are migrants living just outside the hostel do not have even access to basic amenities like water and toilets. While the future scientists could have a decent place to stay and running hot water, the laborers who built these have to walk quite a distance for their morning chores, live in tin shanties and their kids have neither education nor future. It scares me to think of the hundreds if not more working on upcoming MHRD campuses, about whom or their families no one seems to be bothered.
    Science is and will remain a part of the society and its politics By: Jay | 29-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward It seems that many people do not understand that science is for India, not the other way round. There are many glorious moments for ISRO but that does not mean that we have to support each and every project they undertake. Moon missions and claim to find water in moon by ISRO/India is nothing but ridiculous, particularly from Indian national interest. In a country where we severely lack any role model in any walks of life, the following statement in a famous scientific journal “Nature” (30th July, 2009, pp 572-583) becomes more true: “wherever possible, scientists took advantage of the nation’s appetite for heroes.… Social surveys demonstrated that industrialization had not eradicated poverty and the heroic rhetoric of invention had served its purpose”. We also need to keep in mind that “no country can become a superpower, first by developing its science-research, but it can instantly become a science power house when it achieves political super-power status”.
    ISRO already developed such satellites... govt is not using them!By: Pradeep | 29-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward Our govt is in charge for all the poverty “eradication” programs. They consume almost 70% of our annual budget outlay could neither eradicate not contain poverty. Given the way things are going, I don’t think situation will be any different even after a 100 years. ISRO used the LEAST amount of resources to launch a moon probe. Their share of expenditure is negligible compared to what the babus spend for power eradication programs. Inspite of all this, they were able to detect water on moon. So, lets hail them. ISRO launched a number of remote sensing satellites and handed them to the government. These satellites can detect water resources and several foreign countries used these satellites to detect water in their countries. Our govt, inspite of having all these satellites did not use them. What can ISRO do? They did their job and carried on with a moon mission. Lets hope Rahul Gandhi gets the idea to use these satellites to better the lives of people.
    Habit of quoting great people when it suits By: Jay | 28-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward Those who are benefitted by high corruption in almost all govt institutions; medieval, feudal social system are much less in number but highly aggressive, powerful and vocal. Weak voices of poor and disadvantageous people are drowned amidst loud propaganda by those. They find enough reason to quote APJ Kalam or some other people to support present trend of “development” , but they conveniently forget to mention why almost all the indexes of India is going down, why internal security is the biggest threat to our national security (as per our PM)! They never follow Kalam’s advice in any other matter or the way they live (highly corrupt and extravagant life). It’s great achievement (just like winning a Nobel prize) to remain personally honest and live a decent life in India these days.
    Science vs GovernanceBy: Appu | 28-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward Finding water on moon is the domain of science. Finding water in India is the domain of governance and society. Ms Singh has mixed up the two. The way we have managed our country, it will be another 100 years before we can even get to basics of science if she to be to followed. Are you, Ms Singh, agreeing with the left that India should not have atomic deterence before the last poor in India gets his/her roti, kapada aur makaan?
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.