Premium
This is an archive article published on August 6, 2013
Premium

Opinion More of the same

This refers to ‘Modi-hit’ by Shekhar Gupta (IE,August 3). Gupta rightly indicts the two chief ministers,Nitish Kumar and Akhilesh Yadav

The Indian Express

August 6, 2013 03:58 AM IST First published on: Aug 6, 2013 at 03:58 AM IST

* This refers to ‘Modi-hit’ by Shekhar Gupta (IE,August 3). Gupta rightly indicts the two chief ministers,Nitish Kumar and Akhilesh Yadav,who were perceived to be icons of better governance and development,for abandoning their overwhelming mandates and embracing minorityism and votebank populism instead. Their recent missteps are clearly panicked reactions to Narendra Modi’s rise and prominence. I agree entirely that Nitish’s reaction to the Bihar midday meal tragedy was “juvenile”,and Akhilesh’s move to suspend IAS officer Durga Shakti Nagpal “idiotic”. The more things appear to change,the more they stay the same. One is not sure who these two CMs think they are fooling.

— M. Ratan

New Delhi

*VARIOUS political parties still play the secularism card to indulge in outdated identity politics. It seems it is in the best interests of the ruling class to ensure minority communities remain backward and vulnerable. The more vulnerable,the more they can be manipulated; the more backward,the more they feel grateful for a mai-baap sarkar that keeps them dependent on itself.

— Ketan R. Meher

Thane

Gandhi on Eiffel

Advertisement

*THIS refers to ‘Eiffel brand worth is £435 billion’ by Shombit Sengupta (IE,August 4). The writer mentions that even M.K. Gandhi was present at the Exposition Universelle of 1889. This is indeed true. It is interesting to note,however,Gandhi’s thoughts on the Eiffel Tower itself. In chapter 23 (“The great exhibition”) of the first part of his 1927 autobiography,Gandhi wrote that he visited Paris while studying for the bar examination in London. However,he found no beauty in the Eiffel Tower. Quoting Tolstoy,he asserted that it was a symbol of human “absurdity”,and that even though he went up the tower,he felt it was a waste of money. For Gandhi,the Eiffel Tower did not hold much charm.

— V.B. Ganatra

New York

Double standards

*THIS refers to ‘Fearing displacement,Sikh farmers settled in Kutch approach Punjab CM’ (IE,August 4). Over 2,000 Sikh farmers converted large tracts of arid land into cultivable farmland in Kutch,through nearly four decades of hard work. Now the Gujrat government is forcing them to vacate their land by invoking provisions of the Bombay Tenancy and Agriculture Lands Act,1958. Even though the Gujrat High Court has ruled in favour of the farmers,the government has moved the Supreme Court,to appeal against the decision. This is curious. On the one hand,the BJP says that Article 370,which gives J&K special status and prohibits outsiders from owning land in the state,should be abolished. On the other hand,it is essentially doing the same thing in Gujrat.

— Vinod Sharma

Moga

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments