Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

Open to criticism

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • Personal Loan

    In these times of interactive journalism I make it a point to read the blogs this column evokes. From doing this, I have discovered to my huge distress a national characteristic that I thought died with socialism. And, this is our uniquely Indian inability to distinguish between India and the Government of India. In those bad old socialist days when I was growing up, the political atmosphere in India was not very different to countries that lived secret, totalitarian lives behind the ‘iron curtain’. We did not criticise our ‘great’ leaders because that amounted to blasphemy and we did not run a tooth comb through their policies because that amounted to criticism of our ‘great’ country. It was a post-colonial time and the chip we had on our collective shoulders was enormous. I thought it had disintegrated with the new confidence that Indians developed after our moribund economy was opened up in the nineties and after satellite dishes ended our isolation from the rest of the world. Alas, the blogs tell another story.

    My column on the appalling state of India’s infrastructure, last week, evoked a surprisingly robust response. The chip-on-the-shoulder wallahs raged about how this column is always ‘pessimistic’. And those who are really pessimistic about India’s future said that things were never going to improve. And, that all ‘good Indians’ should and do leave for foreign lands. A blogging battle occurred between the two camps. With the chippy ones taking the Mera Bharat Mahaan line: no matter how bad things are in India, it is a better country than ‘developed and depressing’ Britain. The foreign camp said correctly that this was rubbish.

    ... contd.

    Next123
    Critically AcclaimedBy: Pranav | 29-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward Its some people's habbit to find fault in almost anything done by others and then to compliment it by not suggestng any worthwhile alternative... the alternatives if at all they come are given after great pain when several comments/requests are recieved for the same. Ms. Tavleen Singh is perhaps the foremost and definately a bright example of this. And the most noteworthy aspect of this is the fact that she does not fail, even once, to criticise even the fair comments ( though not as per her) recieved in reply to her critically acclaimed articles.Pranav, Delhi
    putting spoke on to the wheel of development.By: shurkumishra | 11-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward respected madam,you will be doing a great service to the country if you can find out the people who are behind the likes of medha patker who donot like India to progress if you can expose these people and find out the source of their funding, people of India will understand their vested interest and will ignore these forces for ever.hope you will kindly give this suggestion a serious thought.shurkumishra
    You need to let people know about herosBy: pradeep4 | 09-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward Let me put things this way: No force on this planet can stop India from rising… period. India is rising (6-9% GDP) because of a few heros who can never be beaten down. Unfortunately, hardly anyone in India knows about these selfless heros who are trying to make a difference. The only reason why heros’ efforts need to be glorified is to inspire others to become heros (BTW: heros care a damn about publicity). Heros bring hope to this country. Talking 99% of the time about villans make people hopeless. Hopeless people take hopeless decisions and elect hopeless leaders. That’s what happened when US people elected bush for the second time. That’s exactly whats happening now. Its only the journalists who can make a difference here. India is going to rise irrespective of politicians… of course at a slower pace
    Heros and their deedsBy: pradeep3 | 09-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward Heros inspire people to perform heroic deeds and make a difference to all those around them. Thats the very reason why we give medals on the republic day! Why doesn’t media medals (print space) to all those individuals who are trying to make a difference? I see 99% of the print space (or no of lines in news articles) dedicated to evil (rape/torture/murder/bribe/govt laxity etc). I rather prefer to see a 50-50 balance between good and evil. I don’t know why the media has this habit of demonizing the rich. Not all rich are bribing monopolists who love to squeeze poor innocent people. There are some great Indian business men because of whom there are atleast a few jobs in our country. I would like to see articles from you explaining their convection. Your articles have such a fury that it makes me feel that if you were given a chance, you would take a gun and shoot poor Advani. I will be happy if you use that fury to inspire people to perform heroic deeds and make a difference.
    You never appreciate heroic deedsBy: pradeep2 | 09-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward Unfortunately, you have this way of articulating things such that you take one mistake of a hero and destroy/demonize/castigate him. You wrote so passionately about infrastructure… not once you mention Vajpayee who got the golden quadrateral project done in a couple of years. You took the lead in criticizing the NDA govt from its communal inclination, but you NEVER commended some of the unique things it has done. Getting the golden quadrateral done is a heroic achievement… even by Chinese standards. You NEVER appreciate the amount of hard work that went into planning and the dedication of all those bureaucrats who made this possible. You don’t need give answers to India’s problems. All you need to do is write about how people went the extra length and performed heroic deeds… one can find quite a number of answers to all these “how-to” questions. Your answers will be quite different from what one learns from successful heroic deeds.
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.