Indian Express
Sign In | Register Now
Newsletter | ePaper
Indian Express >  India > 

'Should non-performing politicos be lynched?'

Font Size
Agencies Posted: Sep 24, 2008 at 1654 hrs IST
Related Stories: Rizwanur case: Todi surrenders, prays for bailTelecom company DGM missing3 out of 4 girls deny rape by SSB men: copsIn dock for destroying Abhaya proof, ex-investigator found deadPrez brother refused to undergo lie detector test: CBISurrender before trial court, SC tells Todi
New Delhi, September 24:: Furious with Union Labour Minister Oscar Fernandez for empathising with workers who killed their boss, the business community on Wednesday said by that measure politicians who do not perform should be lynched.

"If we go by his argument then he should be lynched in his constituency if he does not perform," Indo-Italian Chamber of Commerce (Northern Region) Chairman Diljeet Titus said.

Fernandez had said on Tuesday that "simmering discontent among the workers" led to the lynching incident of L K Chaudhary, CEO of an Italy-based auto-component manufacturer Cerlikon-Graziano in Greater Noida.

"This should serve as a warning for the managements. It is my appeal to the managements that the workers should be dealt with compassion. The workers should not be pushed so hard that they resort to whatever that had happened in Noida," the minister had told reporters at a press conference.

Disputes are integral part of any business, but there is a way to resolve them, Titus said.

"We have legal processes to settle any dispute. If any person is fired without keeping rules in mind, he can approach the court and opt for other mechanisms, but in any case killing an innocent person is not the option," he said.

Ads By Google
There are about 150 Italian joint venture companies in the northern region. "The episode will certainly have an adverse impact on these companies whereas others will also think about their future," Titus who also heads Titus and Company, a law firm, said.

However, Commerce Minister Kamal Nath said on Wednesday condemned the incident and called it "very unfortunate."

Arguing that the disgruntled Unions have always expressed anger in their own way, Titus said: "In the last five years, I cannot remember any such case where the CEO of a company has been murdered by the mob."

He lamented that multinational companies becomes soft targets for such elements because they work honestly and do not pay heed to unlawful demands of local 'netas' and 'gunda' elements.

"Indian businessmen manoeuvre their way by offering 'bakshish' and can get away in such situation with the help of anti-social elements but most MNCs don't follow such tricks and are victimised," he said.

"There is a sense of deep shock among Italian business men, but we cannot comment what will be the long-term impact. We are still assessing the situation," commercial counsellor at Italian Embassy Nicolo Tassoni said.

Ads By Google
Post Comments
Message*
Maximum characters allowed     
 
Name* Email ID*
Subject* Country*
TERMS OF USE:
The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
I agree to the terms of use.
View all Messages [ 45 ]
CEO murdered in Noida by gnsetty on 2008-09-25 08:14:24.770336+05:30
Mr Titus is absolutely right.MNCs do not but most Indian businesses pay soft money to the Goondas to get around any problem.This is a sad day for India's business integration with the world in future.Fernandez must resign or sacked for his total lack of humanity for the dead CEO.Fernandez is behaving as if he is addressing the vote bank.Is this how India's Labour Cabinet Minister leads the workers when they are sacked even if they are not permanent,even if they destroy private property and even if they are not directly employed by the company ? For Fernandez courts don't exist in India for any dispute if workers are sacked.It is time PM sacks this clueless worshipper of the Dynasty.
Oscar's comments by Shankar on 2008-09-25 08:03:10.113401+05:30
May be Oscar was telling Sonia what he will do if he is dropped from the cabinet !
Irresponsible UPA by Kannnan on 2008-09-25 07:32:11.48969+05:30
Well said Diljeet Titus! We should have started that action long time and continued. By this time all the non-performing politicians would have posed problems for Yama and not to Indians.
CPI or AITUC by K Sanjiv on 2008-09-25 06:28:08.284115+05:30
It was no surprise to see D. Raja on a talk show claiming that an apology was not required. It was his union that raised the anger of the workers. The CPI are the nose and tail of the same animal. Never mind which is which. Nothing justifies physical violence. In case Mr. Raja forgot, we do have laws.
Should the politicians be lynched? by Bhuwan on 2008-09-25 06:04:17.0502+05:30
Staart with Arjun Singdh ji, Mulayam and like.
uncouyh politicians by virender on 2008-09-25 03:41:47.333761+05:30
All this thugry started at the time of Mrs.Indera Ghandi and since than it has escalated to the point of no return,u only have to look around and u find Mumta Banerji,Maya wati,Uma Bharti,some of these BADMASH women going around and misleading the poor and illiterate people.Now the new snake has appeared on the surface in the name of Thakery,there are lots of hard working people in the country but these thugs r going to drag every one in the gutter.There is a murder every day in Gurgaon,I lived in Gurgaon from 1950 to 1960 never heard even once about any killing,look at Noida, not a day go by with out a murder.When we leaders like Patel and Fernandes and the rest of pupets one can not except better.
oscar the bastard by james on 2008-09-25 03:13:52.8634+05:30
Oscar is a bloody son of a bitch
He is accountable by Raj on 2008-09-25 01:53:10.322442+05:30
Why is he still a minister, he should be in jail. Why is Indo-Italian Chamber of Commerce not files a low suite
nonperforming ministers by M.K.NARAYANAN on 2008-09-25 00:22:01.038285+05:30
GEORGE FERNADES IS A TRADE UNION LEADER .WHAT HAS HE GOT TO SAY ONTHIS STATEMENT OF THE PRESENT UNION LABOUR MINISTER?
India by Manoj on 2008-09-25 00:11:01.812956+05:30
This guy is a central minister?? God help India. I think if people are put in these positions due to their dog like loyalty to 'the family', then this is bound to happen.
Mr. Oscar Fernandes by Thomas on 2008-09-25 00:00:24.015468+05:30
Mr. Fernandez should be ashamed of himself to talk like this. No workers/union have authority to kill anybody or destroy any property. Will CII ,a stooge of Government condemn the minister publicly? Do they have guts or only they are only court jesters in the court of Sonia and P.M.Sonia Mohan Singh?
should indian politicos be lynched by govind batte on 2008-09-24 23:50:35.7213+05:30
What can we expect from Indian ministers, ruthless, shameless, power seeking, mindless
'Should non-performing politicos be lynched? by Rashmi on 2008-09-24 22:41:44.233756+05:30
Unfortunate and miserable but as our minister are not appointed by competence but being loyalist. Same happened when journalist interview Shivraj Patil and he says that he has full blessing of his party leader means Mrs. Sonia Gandhi. Therefore all our minister don’t need curriculum but just offer loyalty and God save our country from all these incompetent people.Rashmi
civil terrorism by aarti on 2008-09-24 22:30:30.466938+05:30
response to this insident,true
What the minister said is RIGHT, at least partially by Jay on 2008-09-24 22:23:36.331798+05:30
How many common workers’ family have access to internet to post messages in such boards? It’s not so surprising that majority in this forum condemn the Congress minister but very few have the guts and ability to analyze what he said. He NEVER supported the killing, nor do I. But there is a reason why it happened and what industry captains should do to minimize such incidents. We all know how Indian businessmen and industrialists work, particularly in construction, manufacturing and other labor intensive sectors. Majority of them are corrupt to their cores but our system hardly punish them. And due to such people few reasonably Good people are also blamed. What practical ways a common citizen or worker has if s/he is cheated by an industrialist or a politician? Practically nothing. It’s not that surprising that so many extremist movements are going in almost entire country.It’s time to introspect and change ourselves than to gloss over the incident and fail to learn lessons.
Industrial and Labour violence is a shot in foot. by Sunita on 2008-09-24 22:11:13.755743+05:30
It is unacceptable to endorse violence at political level, as this will lead to anarchy and chaos in country.
Balancing Act by Tabassum on 2008-09-24 22:08:07.035534+05:30
We need a 'Balancing Act' that would allow quick remedy of worker and industry dispute. Working class in India lives hand to mouth and jobs are not as plentiful as China, that change is easy. This causes enormous strain. Indian employers may suck enough blood gradually, and may get away due to well known local tactics and corruption, and still not fire their workers. On the other hand the industry may be victimised by corrupt labour unions whose sole job is to interrupt work flow and demand higher wages despite performing poorly. In any situation, killing is unacceptable, and it can not be endorsed at political level at any cost as it will lead to anarchy and chaos all across country. If this is not enough, our judicial system is primitive in performance, but high in spirits and idealism. What we need is a parallel judicial sytem for quick resolution of labour and industrial disputes; and if this can not be done, then this kind of instances may become routine with industrial progress.
Not so rosy future ahead by B. B. Goel on 2008-09-24 22:06:58.895147+05:30
I worked in an Indian MNC some years back. I found that they do all sort of crimes and corruptions, cheat its own employees, and workers hardly have any way left to seek justice. Even top management is not spared. Only one person (it’s mainly a family owned business) or members of his family can do just anything. Today Transparency international ranked India 85th in global corruption. The level of corruption is growing and there is hardly any civilized way left to address any injustice or crime. So far I know, not a single industrialists or businessman ever been convicted for doing crimes like food adulteration, cheating workers etc. Corrupt industrialist never been punished in India, unlike USA or other civilized countries. Uncontrolled capitalism and “winners take it all” mentality among so-called successful people without giving due credit to its work force will eventually lead to total collapse of the society, as we witness in India.
Outrageous From Oscar by Sunil Maingi on 2008-09-24 21:11:04.942108+05:30
The labour minister’s comment was outrageous and totally unacceptable. Why is the able parliamentarian justifying violence? Such comments show his true beliefs, which are contrary to the oath he took, to uphold the rule of law while performing his duties as a Minister. The time has come to invoke a law against such vile attempts of vote bank politics and appeasement measures.The minister is doing a huge disservice to the workers, if he justifies violence to resolve any dispute. If violence is encouraged, then industry will pack up, and these very workers will be unemployed. Will he then justify robbery and theft as a means of sustenance?
How can it be different? by B. B. Goel on 2008-09-24 20:43:51.400348+05:30
Increase in GDP and par capita income can not gloss over the dangerous consequences of increasingly huge gap of wealth distribution and almost total failure of our civic society. General public, common workers have lost faith on the system. Due to age old practice by businessmen and industrialists to use intimidation, force and collusion with govt officials, police, criminals and politicians they cheat workers; give false, fabricated financial data while filing tax and deciding the salary and other benefits of common workers, deprive general public a safe, civic life. Many industrialists force its work force to work in dangerous conditions. Such practices are more prevalent in places like places in North India. Almost everyone is provoked to take laws in their own hands. None has any faith left on the whole system. Urban terrorism, extremist movements allover India, killing of CEO in Noida is just the tip of the huge iceberg. Army, police can not do it.
View all Messages [ 45 ]
Group Websites : Express India | Financial Express | Screen India | Loksatta | Kashmir Live | Biz Publications
Privacy Policy | Feedback | Site MapThe Indian Express Group | Work With Us | Adverise With Us | Contact Us© 2008 Indian Express Newspapers (Mumbai) Ltd. All rights reserved
*Recipient(s) name *
*Recipient(s) e-mail address *
(Separate addresses by commas)
*Your Name *
*Your e-mail address *
Select your Country
Comments(optional)

The name(s) and e-mail address(es) you provide will
not be used for any purpose other than to inform the
recipient(s) of your identity. (*mandatory field)
 
Close