Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

Our Chinese Wall

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • China may have recently returned to our headlines — at least on some news TV channels — and we can argue about whether the threat on the border is real or exaggerated. But, for a moment, think the unthinkable. Could it be, could it just be, that we are a nation deeply scared of China? Not merely Sinophobic in the sense that many other major nations like the US, Japan and Korea may be, but genuinely scared. Since the short, sharp and disastrous war of 1962, could it just be that we have brainwashed two or three generations of Indians to live in dread of the dragon? We glare at Pakistan all the time, we look the US in the eye all the time now. But China? Just mention the word and we start talking trade, culture, shared values, centuries-old contacts and so on. Have we, over the decades, internalised, and institutionalised, a psychology of pretending a Chinese challenge, economically, politically and militarily (I have chosen that order deliberately) does not exist? And believing that, if it does, we can do nothing about it?

    We flatter ourselves often enough comparing ourselves with China, we feel flattered when, rather occasionally, we are mentioned in the same breath as China. We were obviously so thrilled when some in the global financial community started saying, particularly when they came visiting India, that China “and India” were now key to a global recovery. But let’s be honest. Do facts on the ground justify that ranking? Consider just one fact. Since the governments around the world initiated stimulus packages exactly a year ago, the Chinese banking system has pumped an additional Rs 70 lakh crore of credit in their economy. Compare this with the total credit currently outstanding in our entire economy: just about Rs 27 lakh crore. So the Chinese, in less than a year, have shored up their economy and manufacturing by releasing additional credit that is two-and-a-half-times all credit of all times in India. And we, at the same time, are so self-congratulatory, we want to teach financial regulation to the world, and our central bank is fighting so fiercely to guard its bureaucratic turf it might be an interesting idea to send some Mint Street troopers to sort out the Chinese on the Ladakh border.

    ... contd.

    Next1234
    TraitorBy: S.Rama | 07-Nov-2009 Reply | Forward It is precisely traitorous and Quisling-attitudes like this that denigrate the superiority of India state and values system. We can repel any attack for we are uniquely valourous and brave. Bring the heat on.
    ASIAN MIRACLEBy: SELVARAJOO | 30-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward China is a powerful nation but India is the world.Look at the complexity of people,cultures and religion prevailing even after thousands of years of foreign domination.China puts all the minds of their people together to achieve and build the nation to sucess as you see today.They have surplus of hundreds of trillion dollars and it is best toutilize for the housing sector to improve the quality of 1.3 billion people and lets hope the Chinese people are wise.For India it is time to open their hearts and hands to the Indian people and their neighbours.It is time for all Asian people to live in peace and prosperty for a thousand years.
    Be objectve, Mr Shekhar!By: The nationalist | 19-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward Under Shekhar Gupta, the Indian Express seems to have fine tuned the art of toing the Congress line while showcasing the anti-establishment vintage! The so-called clean and well meaning image of our PM becomes very handy tool in doing so. As for China, can he also focus on Govt's preparedness to face agression even if it may not be probable according to him? What is the harm in being militarily strong?
    Communists can never be trusted.By: Himanshu | 18-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward You only have to read Chinese history and a book on Mao's life in which there was a section about the 1962 war with India that Chinese can never be trusted. Also isn't it well known that Chinese soldier's were taught to yell 'Hindi Chini bhai bhai' while preparing to violate our borders at the same time.
    Good oneBy: Jungle cat | 16-Sep-2009 Reply | Forward Despite the others comments, I maintain that it is good piece. We are a pygmy compared to China in almost all matters-no matter what some television channels say. China is big neighbor- growing day by day-and in whose shadows we are destined to live. The only way forward is to make peace with China even it costs some exchange of territory. One of the comments talks about 1962 China-India war and Dalvi’s book. I am a retired Army man and know about it better. The blame of 1962 fiasco can not be passed on to political leadership alone. Even today our armed forces are wary of China- Do not push them to precipice by your civilian jingoism
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.