Premium
This is an archive article published on September 10, 2009

PM pushes 2nd Mumbai airport,Jairam grounds it

Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh has locked horns with Maharashtra govt and Civil Aviation Ministry by reopening the debate on site selection for Navi Mumbai airport.

Barely months after Prime Minister Manmohan Singh broke the impasse on the Navi Mumbai airport by clearing the amendment of the Coastal Regulation Zone Act to permit construction of greenfield airports,Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh has locked horns with the Maharashtra government and the Civil Aviation Ministry by reopening the debate on the selection of the site itself. And,in the process,putting a question mark on the project itself.

In June,Ramesh wrote to Maharashtra Chief Minister Ashok Chavan to “clarify” that the Environment Ministry has “at no point given any in-principle approval for the proposed airport”. More so,on the amendment to the CRZ Act,he said that it only made construction of a greenfield airport a “permissible” activity but did not preclude granting of environment clearances.

He then opened up the question of the Rewas-Mandwa site that was selected about a decade ago and dropped due to massive protests from villagers. The alternate site where the airport is being planned has already been identified and land acquisition proceedings started.

Story continues below this ad

But Ramesh has turned the clock back and asked why the state government considered the Rewas-Mandwa site as “more sensitive” than the present one.

“The MoE&F (Ministry of Environment and Forests) is not clear on what basis this assertion is being made by the state government,” he wrote.

This has left the Ministry of Civil Aviation and Maharashtra government baffled. All these arguments had been gone through over the past five years and it was the PM,as in-charge of Environment Ministry during the last months of the previous term,who directed his officials to find a solution to the problems the new site was facing because of being in the CRZ and the presence of mangroves.

On February 10,Principal Secretary to PM T K A Nair held a meeting with all officials concerned where it was decided to follow the same route for Navi Mumbai as was done to build airports in Andaman & Nicobar Islands and Lakshadweep. This route required making exception to the CRZ notification just like it was done in these two places.

Story continues below this ad

Subsequently,the Law Ministry was roped in and finally on May 15,the amendment was made to the CRZ Act. Within a month after Ramesh took over as the new Environment Minister,he started raising concerns over the “ecological damage” the new airport would cause.

Defending his stand during the Idea Exchange programme at The Indian Express on Tuesday,Ramesh said that the region had mangrove forests which cannot be re-grown. “We have asked CIDCO (City Industrial and Development Corporation) to do a detailed environment impact assessment of this location. They have hired IIT Bombay and it could take anywhere between 9 to 12 months… We should find a way of building an international airport which does not involve loss of mangrove areas and valuable marshy land… If the mangroves can be regenerated,we can go ahead. If they can’t,we may have to look at other options,” he said.

The Navi Mumbai airport is critical for Mumbai because major expansion is ruled out in the existing airport. Given that the air traffic projections for the city are only increasing,it was decided to press ahead with the Navi Mumbai airport which will help ease pressure from the current airport and cater to long-term demand.

It is envisioned as a state-of-the art airport with two parallel runways that would broad and big enough to accommodate the Airbus 380s.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement