Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

Prosecution urges inquiry to determine if Kasab is juvenile

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • Kasab
    Is Kasab juvinile?
    Ujjwal Nikam, special public prosecutor in the November 26 Mumbai terror attack case, on Tuesday urged the trial court to order an inquiry to determine whether prime accused Mohammed Ajmal Amir Kasab was a juvenile when he allegedly committed crime.

    The prosecution asking for an inquiry before the start of the trial is considered significant in legal circles as it does want the accused to plead later that the trial had been vitiated as he was a juvenile. The court has already rejected Kasab's plea that he was a juvenile at the time of commission of offence (November 26, 2008) when he and others had struck terror in Mumbai by firing at people, killing 166, in important public places.

    However, judge M L Tahilyani had kept the issue open and observed that at any time during trial if the court feels that the age of the accused be determined it may order an inquiry. Kasab's lawyer Abbas Kazmi said he had no objection to the court holding an inquiry to determine the age of the accused. The inquiry would include scientific tests, he said. The judge heard Nikam and Kazmi on the issue and reserved the order until tomorrow. Nikam pleaded he should be allowed to lead evidence in the inquiry. There was sufficient evidence to prove that Kasab was not a juvenile, he said.

    Ads by Google

    Kasab seeks Urdu chargesheet again

    Prime accused in Mumbai terror attack case Mohammed Ajmal Amir Kasab on Tuesday asked for an Urdu translation of the 11,000-page chargesheet in order to build up his defence, but the prosecution strongly opposed his plea, saying he was adopting "delay tactics" to prolong the trial. Kasab's lawyer Abbas Kazmi also pleaded for four weeks' time to reply to prosecution on charges proposed to be framed against him. Judge M L Tahilyani has reserved order until tomorrow on Kasab's plea for Urdu translation of chargesheet and one-month adjournment to reply to prosecution's proposed charges.

    Kazmi asked for an Urdu translation of the chargesheet, saying the accused could not understand any other language and therefore would not be in a position to give instructions to him regarding his defence in the trial. Opposing Kasab's plea, Special Public Prosecutor Ujjwal Nikam said there was no provision in law to provide the chargesheet in the language understood by the accused. The official language of the court, decided by the Government of Maharashtra through a circular on July 23, 1998, was Marathi.

    Copies of the chargesheet in English and Marathi were already provided to the accused, he said. This is the second time Kasab pleading for an Urdu translation of the chargesheet.

    Earlier, he made a similar request to a magistrate (before whom he was produced for remand) but the court had rejected his plea. In another development, co-accused Sabaudin Ahmed filed an application, alleging that Crime Branch police had used third degree methods to "torture" him during his arrest earlier. The application was filed by his lawyer Ejaz Naqvi who could not satisfy the court's query as to why he was making a grievance after a considerable lapse of time particularly when the accused had the opportunity earlier to tell the court.

    Sabauddin's application also alleged that FBI slueths, James and Mike, had interrogated him when he was in the custody of Crime Branch. The accused demanded that the FBI officers be arrested as they had no authority to grill him.

    Judge M L Tahilyani asked Investigating Officer Ramesh Mahale to file a reply to these allegations. In another application, Sabauddin urged for return of his belongings at the time of his arrest. The court has asked the investigating officer to file a reply on this plea also.

    Meanwhile, the lawyers appeared for co-accused Faheem Ansari, Saba Qureshi and Nilesh Jadhav, today sought time to reply to prosecution's proposed charges. The duo submitted that they had not yet seen the chargesheet. The court would decide their plea tomorrow. Kasab is facing charges of gunning down 166 perons along with nine others on November 26 last year following a conspiracy hatched by LeT in Pakistan. Faheem and Sabauddin are charged with providing maps of target locations to the conspirators. Kasab was captured alive, while others were killed by armed forces in a pitched battle.

    We are not going HANG kasab!!!By: Prashanth | 22-Apr-2009 Reply | Forward It will take 5 years of time to SC to declare death sentence to Kasab because the case will come alltogether from district court, High court, reappeal in High court, supreme court, reappeal in supreme court, requesting supreme court to give parden, then president permission to hang, requesting president by kasab's mother to give parden, since it last in the list of criminals who got death sentence president will take 5 years [ as mentioned by our great Chidhamburam ].... finally he will not be hanged because it will hurt some community... so kasab will live life long with [with his freind Afzal GURU] special treatment!!!.....'IT HAPPENS ONLY IN INDIA'
    Our Laws need to adapt to modern realitiesBy: KD | 22-Apr-2009 Reply | Forward Everybody is aware of how terrorist organisations have started brainwashing young teenagers into carrying out dastardly acts similar to 26/11. The last thing we want at this time is a loophole in the law that allows such individuals to get away lightly after performing the most heinous of crimes. The magnitude of 26/11 and the cold blooded approach of the terrorists involved showed no juvenile behaviour whatsover. They should be treated as adults and punished accordingly. Even now there is no sign of remorse on the face of the lone survivor.
    Let's Ask Pakistan to send details!By: Ronald | 22-Apr-2009 Reply | Forward Let Kasav ask Pakistan to send his birth certificate - the onus being on him and his lawyer to prove that he was a juvenile.
    Our criminal justice system is so fine in INDIA that honest and innocent are made to suffer and gets murdered also and criminals and traitors are protected. By: B S GANESH, BANGALORE | 21-Apr-2009 Reply | Forward Our criminal justice system is so fine in INDIA that honest and innocent are made to suffer and gets murdered also and criminals and traitors are protected. Is it not a shame to the country and its judiciar?B S GANESH, BANGALORE
    Kasab is juvenile - does it matterBy: Vijay | 21-Apr-2009 Reply | Forward It does not matter if Kasab was juvenile when he massacred hundreds of innocent people. This crime was premeditated and Kasab was fully aware of his actions. There is no need to have a lengthy trial, it should be completed with in one day and Bal Thackeray has suggested he should be hanged in gateway if India
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.