Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

Republic of control

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • The self-appointed custodians of Indian culture and values raised their ugly head on Monday, when a bunch of hooligans called the Sri Rama Sene attacked young women in a pub in Mangalore. The women’s alleged wrongdoing: drinking and dancing, which the group sees to be a perversion of Indian culture and tradition. Leave aside the plain illegality of such an attack, but the Sri Ram Sene cannot seriously believe that drinking and dancing are alien to Indian culture — if they knew their history, they would know otherwise. But the fact is that the Sri Rama Sene does not know its Ramayana, or the deep and long tradition of tolerance that Indian culture is most famous for.

    Sadly, the Mangalore incident is hardly a one-off affair. It is just one incident in a long line of incidents — the destruction of an art exhibition in Baroda, the vandalism on Valentine’s Day, threats to M.F. Hussain, to name just a few — which expose the extreme intolerance and thuggishness of a certain section of society. Unfortunately, many of these hooligans are well-organised groups of politically motivated individuals who do usually have formal or informal links with many mainstream right-wing parties. The BJP may deny direct association with the Rama Sene, but what about the Bajrang Dal?

    Ads by Google

    Still, if the tendency to police or control culture were purely the domain of a fringe element, there would be less to worry about. Sadly, the trend extends well into the mainstream (right, centre and left), and even if it ends up being expressed in less violent, and more subtle terms, it is no less damaging to society. It is this systemic tendency to lean towards control of culture, creativity and independent thinking, which is worrying.

    ... contd.

    Next1234
    Republic of Control ... and ill logicBy: VK | 30-Jan-2009 Reply | Forward Dear Dhiraj - Kudos on a thoughtful article. Many readers seem to have responded critically without due thought. Freedom from control doesn't mean a free cheque to anarchy. Is the co-existence of freedom and responsible ethics such an alien idea? Excess of everything is bad, whether control or freedom. But in the final analysis abundant freedom with sprinkling of control can yield un-paralleled results. Actions of the moral brigade seem outbursts of frustration than an urge to protect social bindings. And do they assume attacking girls an act of bravery? It's nothing but disgusting cowardice!
    Republic of control By: B.S.Pai | 29-Jan-2009 Reply | Forward The article is tall on philosophy and short on reality. Control has always been there on every form of human activity from time immemorial. What form it should take is the philosophical question and not whether it should be there. Young children mainly college going teens are routinely found in pubs and bars drinking and dancing in major educational centres. Now the question is whether it is permissible behaviour or not. it depends on the outlook of each person. I would certainly not like my children to do so. And so I believe that lakhs of parents who send their hard earned money to their children for educating themagree with me. Beating them out of the pub is not the solution nor is it the right way to correct the wayward behaviour but I certainly think some control by someone is required to correct their behaviour. Parental control was one of them. In its absence we find such people taking over. Time parents gave a thought over it.
    Republic of controlBy: Prabodh | 29-Jan-2009 Reply | Forward Why not ban the usage of God's name for any organisation?
    Republic of controlBy: Raman SK | 29-Jan-2009 Reply | Forward How many of us would like our children to follow the example of these pub culture youths who get exposure to drugs and free sex thru the so called 'freedom' supported by the TRP driven media
    This needs a re-writeBy: anonymous | 29-Jan-2009 Reply | Forward This article lacks deep analysis of important issues and the significant conclusions it draws that we should consider ironically suffer in fact in the process. For instance, a media blitz can in fact *shape"* tastes of consumers that this article ignores by attributing all agency to the consumer. India's education system is now significantly private (in spite of curricula) and indeed it is precisely the *lack of control* and on any quality standards that should concern us all.
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.