You are here: IE »   Story

Row as BJP minister calls modern art pseudo

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • Discount UK Shopping

    The opening of the southern regional branch of the National Gallery of Modern Art at Bangalore on Wednesday was marred by a snap protest by artists over a remark on modern art made by Karnataka Minister of Medical Education Ramachandra Gowda.

    The minister, in the course of his speech as one of the main invitees at the event alongside Union Minister of Tourism and Culture Ambika Soni, said, “modern art has become a medium for pseudo intellectuals to insult ancient Indian culture.”

    “I regret to say some people like to run down ancient art due to their distorted and perverted thinking,” said Ramachandra Gowda.

    While the minister was still speaking, a group of artists from Karnataka raised their voices in protest against the comment. “Mr Gowda, you have no right to speak about modern art, you know nothing about it. We object to your remarks,” said M S Murthy, an artist and director of ‘Bhoomi - the centre for artists’ in Bangalore. He was joined by other local artists like Anandani and C Chandrashekhar.

    Ads by Google

    Enraged by the intervention, the minister said, “I have the freedom of speech.”

    When the group of artists continued to object to the remarks, the minister asked the police to throw them out.

    The artists were then forced out and some sections of the crowd too left the venue, saying, “we are with the artists, there is no need to be fascists.”

    “I am not against modern art. I am only saying it should be within cultural norms. My remarks are only for those who have distorted Indian culture and heritage, not for everyone,”Gowda later clarified.

    BJP minister calls modern art pseudoBy: MANAS SHOME | 19-Feb-2009 Reply | Forward Ministers in our country always make crude remarks to buy publicity. As for this case, (1) freedom of speech as per constitution should not harm the sentiments of people in a democracy (2) art as a unique expression of an artist is creativity beyond "cultural norms" (where norms are always shaped by people) and no artist really insults anything - it is always based on popular perception of a specific section of society under a certain societal context only - if you cannot tolerate some form of art, don't see it; nobody binds you to do that (3) understanding modern art, or any form of art for that matter, takes time and pain, watching on and on for hours to really appreciate it - which I presume ministers will not do.
    freedom of speechBy: sanjay bansal | 19-Feb-2009 Reply | Forward sir if you donot like ministers comments then not listen it or read it. if you criticize somebody you your self have the patiance to listen somebody.
    THE STATESMANBy: SANJAY BANSAL | 19-Feb-2009 Reply | Forward EVERYBODY HAVE FREEDOM OF SPEECH IN DEMOCRACY EXCEPT JOUNALIST OF THE STATESMAN OF CULCUTTA.NO NEWS PAPER IN INDIA HAVE CONDEMMED THE ARREST OF THIER FELLOW JOURNOULIST IS NOT IS STRANGE. THIS IS CALLED PSEDO-SECULARISM-JOURNALISM.
    ArtBy: soc | 19-Feb-2009 Reply | Forward Karnataka is a case in study of Fascism on rise. Intolerance for minorities, governmental sponsorship of superstition, inability to bring to justice attackers or women or even attempt to justify it, and now intolerance for art form. Be it modern or traditional art, art is art. Sometimes if it is distasteful, it will disappear from the consciousness. Only what is relevant will remain in memory of people.Who are these folks, with lack of understanding or knowledge to comment on matters of art. Who is the real pseudo-intellectual.
    Modern ArtsBy: Hans Mash | 19-Feb-2009 Reply | Forward It is true Modern art is being used as a medium of expression by some Mod Artist to show their anger on Religion and sentiments of the people.SO what Mr Gowda has pointed is true and a frank expression .Many of these Artists may not have respect for any religion and sentiments but by being rude and vulgar they think they can get cheap publicity .Some Artists like MF Hussain have made this as a business model and have tried to sell them to public .If these people think they have a right to show Vulgarity on their Arts then every religious minded person in our country has a right to protest and and the law should punish such short sighted artists .
    Row as BJP minister calls modern art pseudoBy: prema | 19-Feb-2009 Reply | Forward It is obvious that the so-called protectors of culture cannot appreciate any Indian art traditional or modern. At this juncture I request our Minister to take some time off to visit the circle Mariamma temple in 18th Cross Malleswaram. I single out one sculpture of a woman on the gopuram that cannot be perceived as art in any sense and would be better classified as pornographic. So Minister can it be left there because it has a religious sanction? What a shame? Please rise wise folks.....
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.