Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

The end of ideology

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • Ideology recast

    After the others on whom blame may be pinned are exhausted, the leader and his circle turn on the ideals on which, on the ‘ideology’ for the realisation of which the movement had commenced and the party had been founded. So, one day they lunge for a ‘hard’ formulation — to win back the ‘core constituency’, they reason. The next, they lunge for a ‘soft’ formulation; one day they are stressing ‘our religion’, the next ‘our culture’; one day it is ‘return to basics’, the next ‘changing with the times’; one day they are declaring their faith in our history castigating persecutors of the past and their current heirs and apparitions, the next they are swearing by inclusiveness and geography¿ One day it is ‘reforms’, the next ‘Reforms with a human face’... One day it is ‘peasants’, the next ‘workers’, the third the inclusive ‘toiling masses’. And they are never short of quotations from the original leaders to justify each twist.

    Ads by Google

    What the leader and his speechwriters convince themselves are sparkling new formulations, are, in fact, just clichés. “The party stands for a strong and prosperous India” — but which party doesn’t? “The party will make the 21st century, India’s century” — but which party says it won’t? Can one not go on adding to that declaration, and it would be just as acceptable? “The party stands for a strong and prosperous India, an India at peace with itself and the world”? “The party stands for a strong and prosperous India, an India at peace with itself and the world, an India in which no one goes to bed hungry”? “The party stands for a strong and prosperous India, an India at peace with itself and the world, an India in which no one goes to bed hungry, one in which the benefits of growth are shared by all”?

    ... contd.

    Next1234
    come backBy: Kartik Bhatt | 31-Jul-2009 Reply | Forward As a person who has sold himself and his pen to BJP for Rajya Sabha membership, stability, money, and power, you have lost your credibility, Shourie. You are just a propaganda machine, a loudspeaker, of the political party you are criticizing, of the political party and its leaders you are unable to name in your above blah blah. We still love you but don't trust you anymore. Choose one thing between jornalism and politics--as long as you are doing both, you are trustworthy and credible in neither. Not satisfied with a party? make one of your own; hopeless with the system and constitution? tell us how it should be, write a new constitution and publish it as a new book. You are a worthy son of India, who has fallen into the gutter: come back to us.
    Ideolpogical competitionBy: Dr.T.V.Mathew | 16-Jul-2009 Reply | Forward There is an element of truth in Shoury's analysis of ideology.Even though parties lack ideology, Indian voters appear to be more rational and they seem to understand what Shourie is talking about.Political parties in India tried to appeal to different sets of ideologies to appeal to voters as Shourie says. However the party he represents seem to have distorted the ideology for political convenience and one expects Shorie to focus on that aspect so that the party could return to the ideology it stands for in ts true spirit, with values of tolerance,inclusive vision....Some parties pursed a caste oriented ideology, others religion/region based/oriented ideology.But Indian voters understood the game that is going on and dispel politics of divide.congrats to the average Indian voter who is rational,and well informed.Thanks to our media as well
    loss of ideologyBy: N. S Parameswaran | 16-Jul-2009 Reply | Forward This article is written clearly with Mr Advani and his 'henchmen' in mind. Would be interesting to watch how BJP reacts if it reacts at all. They may just ignore this as the ranting of an 'idealist' and ignore Mr Shourie.I have one question to Mr Shourie - why did he not raise these issues earlier or in the party fora. It is all well to write such 'third person' articles in pieces. You should walk the talk yourself - if you do not like it leave the party. It will give you more credibility.That apart - this is true of all organizations - not just political parties. see what is happening in BCCI.Also it is true of humanity in general - only in India it seems to be at its worst now.
    Inner party democracy is a must for a secular democracy to prosperBy: Abhijit | 15-Jul-2009 Reply | Forward Is there any democracy in any party in India? NO. Is there any way for a person with true leadership quality, honesty and wisdom but without powerful family backing and cronyism to prosper in Indian politics? NO. In other words, there is almost no hope that India will ever get a Barack Obama in near future. This is true for almost all democratic institutions in India, be it electoral politics, judiciary, bureaucracy, scientific institutions, army, police and so on.
    Think beyond politics and you will get a frightening bigger picture of IndiaBy: jay | 15-Jul-2009 Reply | Forward It’s not the politics only that are showing the symptoms of what Mr Shourie is telling. Each and every aspect of life and profession in India has that symptom. So called respected professions like doctors, professors, scientists, technocrats every one is affected by it. After all, all these people are coming from the same society that supply politician, police, lawyer, army and anything else that we blame for our ill. We think that by teaching corruption, lies and deception in the name of “reality”, we can insulate ourselves from those. So it’s useless to write songs and blame children when they kick out old parents when our own kids grow up with all senses of the same “reality” we taught them. It’s impossible to bring up a kid with healthy mind and body in India today. Unless we pay heed to people like Arun and very few rational and honest people still alive in India, we will pay much more miserable price in future, as a country and as general citizen.
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.