Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

The fire this time

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • This time it is different. Forget Batla House, forget Malegaon, or Godhra or Ayodhya. Set aside the normal incivilities about minority community or Hindu terrorism.

    This is war. This is not a problem of the government or of a political party. It is an attack on the Indian state. It is an attack on all political parties, secular and communal, Left and Right, on fundamentalists of all faiths and of no faith.

    It is an attack on Mumbai and on Maharashtra and on every city and every state of the Union of India. It is an attack on all

    Indians as much as all those who are our guests. Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam. All our guests are our family.

    This is India’s own 9/11.

    The world and India will never be the same again. India has stood alone thus far for 60 years in South Asia and indeed Southeast Asia as the one nation-state which has not broken up. It has never had a national civil war. It has contained all its enemies within — whether we mean Khalistan, Nagaland, Kashmiri separatists, communalists, or Naxalites. The lives of our soldiers and our police, our citizens and even our leaders have been sacrificed to achieve that.

    Ads by Google

    But when it has come to the enemy without, the Indian state has been notoriously soft. It was unprepared against China in 1962 and against Pakistan in Kargil. It was held at ransom in Kandahar. This has happened once again. This week, India was exposed, stripped naked and assaulted. The attack was thoroughly planned, immensely audacious and devastatingly successful. A small number of determined, well-trained, dedicated warriors managed to hold the millions of Mumbai and the billion-plus of India at their mercy.

    It happened without any warning. Yet it must have been months in planning. No one — police, intelligence services, RAW or ATS or CBI — had the slightest inkling of what was afoot. All systems failed. The system itself failed. This is not SIMI, or Huji, LeT or Indian Mujahideen. These are not terrorists. They are guerrilla warriors. They have a global perspective. They are not fighting just India or Indians. They are fighting a global society which is tolerant and free.

    This is the first full-scale attack by global Islamism on India. After New York and Washington DC, London, Madrid and Bali, this continues its unrelenting war against the world. It is a war with the West; and like it or not India is a part of the West.

    Who says so? Osama Bin Laden.

    This is why the guerrillas demanded all those who held British and American passports. And this is why they attacked Nariman House: of all the “others”, none is more “other” than Jews as far as the Islamist is concerned. They came to India and to Mumbai in particular because they knew that in the centre of India’s global heartland they would pick up people from around the world. They knew it would be easy to find vulnerable foreigners in India.

    That is not a cause for complacency, for breathing a sigh of relief, for consoling ourselves that it is not a regular communalist attack, not Muslims on Hindus or vice versa. Don’t say, so all is fine, they came for the foreigners, we can get back to normal life now.

    Remember the oft-quoted words of Dietrich Bonhoffer, a Christian martyred by the Nazis: “When they came for the Jews I said I was not a Jew. When they came for the Communists, I said I was not a Communist. Now they have come for me.”

    Right now, we are all Jews.

    India is on trial. Not just India, Bharat as well. But whose India ? India of the secularist or of the Hindutva believer? Of the Akali or of the Buddhist, of the Christians of Orissa and Kerala and Karnataka or their killers? Of the Dalit or the OBC or the Brahmins and Thakurs? Of the Gurjjars and Meenas and the Marathi Manoos or the Bihari road worker hounded across the land from Assam to Mumbai? Are we each merely an entry in a vote-bank, ready material for manipulation in our march to the ballot box?

    Who speaks any longer for all of India? Sadly, no single party, no single leader, no civil society group. There is no longer a Mohandas or a Vallabhbhai or a Jawaharlal or even a Jayaprakash. Yet the hour demands unity of purpose and nobility of vision. It demands all hands to the mast, all shoulders to the wheel. No single voice is loud enough to be heard by all. We need a chorus of all our voices. It is a test of leadership.

    Can India’s political parties, tested for 60 years in the crucible of democracy, rise to this occasion and save our country? Can we set aside partisanship of our politics and forge a united front? Can the two major parties set aside differences in their visions of India and weave a common narrative of why India is a nation, united and single? Can we give our unreserved support to

    those who are fighting at the risk of their lives in our security services now and in the foreseeable future?

    The time for partisanship will come again. But now we need a national dialogue on the commonalities which unite us, to fight forces which threaten to destroy the nation-state. We need a truce among us to fight those who war against us.

    In other times and other countries, during emergencies such as war, political parties have sunk their differences and forged a government of national unity. Has the time come to do that in India?

    Is this an Emergency?

    The writer is a member of the British House of Lords

    express@expressindia.com

    ELOQUENCE CANNOT REPLACE STRONG ACTIONBy: BHARATMATAKIJAI | 28-Nov-2008 Reply | Forward Easy to write all this from behind the ivory tower Desai! First and foremost we need a young leader capable of taking the bull by the horns! Look at the politicians that we elect ... buddas and buddis.. who have no nerve, only interested in filling their own coffers. Our lame-duck PM has come up with the standard excuse that our neighbour is involved! What a good excuse for mis-governance and lack of guts!! And how come that everytime we know that our neighbour is involved but we do nothing about it Mr. PM??? Enough is enough!! Our PM has to be sent back to where he belongs - behind a IMF Desk and the lady has to be sent back to where she came from Italy! Time we got some dynamic leadership that understands and knows how to deal with this modern from of warfare!! Lame-ducks will not do anymore.... WAKE UP !!
    Preparedness to stop further such acts By: Mailin | 28-Nov-2008 Reply | Forward When it comes to technology and competence to use the intelligence (forget generating intelligence) India is far behind. One thing is to get information (intelligence or incident reporting) authorities are clueless what to do about it (it seems). example: There a foreign ship in Indian seas few months back and when the local fishermen went to police the 'buck' was passed to coastal guards. And by the time authorities who could act came to know about it, it was too late the ships had vanished. This shows that our system/authorities are years behind to deal with current perpetrators/terrorist/criminals. Have you seen the rifle used by constable (ancient) and ability of them to use it (anybody's guess). The people in the authorities are dedicated just by the fact that they are working for those departments. It is our government ability to up skill them, better remunerate them is the obstacle to their performance.Government(politicians) should pull-up socks and work for the COUNTRY
    The fire this timeBy: Chary | 28-Nov-2008 Reply | Forward Instead of penning this vacuous rubbish Desai would do well to advise his friend in Delhi to run a strong and clean Government. When you have a weak PM and a mornic fop as HM and a party leader who is interested in handing over India to her son all tyhe sacrifices of MEN like Kharkare and Kamte is such a waste. Desai need not feel ashamed . even those who should act --in Delhi or Mumbai-are just full of words which mean nothing!
    Holy Pontifications of the Lord!By: A Gokak | 28-Nov-2008 Reply | Forward National dialogue in the times of Madam at the helm and quislings in power? So much piffle and verbal sophistry. Is the writer aware of the numbers of Indians killed by the terrorists in the last 2-3 days, and also in the last 3 decades while the world watched and took sides, using similar detached ponificating verbal sophistry over the heads of third world savages? All it proves is that for the writer, like for the rest of the world, Indian blood is cheaper than water, as compared to the foreigners' -- even the colonisers-- who reduced India to the poorest from the richest nation on earth in the matter of less than a century! Stick to your cushy Manor, Meghnad!
    The fire this timeBy: chary | 28-Nov-2008 Reply | Forward Well said, Gokak!
    Root causesBy: punk | 28-Nov-2008 Reply | Forward More hope than Substance. We have umpteen 9/11s in this countryfro last 15 years and every time the journos say this is the time to correct the situation. The rhino skinned politicos and an equally thick skinned people weep for a while and get on with what they know best...Factionalism, minority pampering, caste based pamepering et el.If at all India is ever to improve, it has to eradicate caste and religion from the school admission forms. It has to dissolve all the reservations based on caste and religion.If at all the govt need to give let these be hard cash. Do not undermine the institutions with fractionalism of caste and religion.Will it ever happen? I am 35 and probably will leave another 40 years. Can the people discard caste and religion and start behaving as equals? My last 35 years says otherwise
    Absolutely RightBy: Sushant | 28-Nov-2008 Reply | Forward I fully agree with you. Caste and religious bigotry are two things that are still holding back India. I am 35 too and I houpe this will change but I doubt it.
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.