You are here: IE »   Story

The Home Minister needs enlightenment

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • Discount UK Shopping

    First, let me say that in my humble opinion the Home Minister is right to reach out to Muslims. With the Taliban at our doorstep, it is very important for India’s Muslims to understand that the way of the Taliban is not their way. Muslims in the Indian subcontinent have for centuries had a civilisation and culture that is very different from the Wahabi Islam being promoted by Islamists everywhere. Let me give you one small but important example. It is not part of Indian Muslim culture for women to be treated as human bundles to be veiled and locked indoors, illiterate and helpless. That is the Taliban way and we must make sure that they keep their ideas to themselves or take them back to Saudi Arabia where a woman can be jailed for wandering about without a man. And, whipped if seen in the company of a man who is not a relative. Muslims in India have never subscribed to such barbarous practices.

    What puzzles me about Mr Chidambaram’s exercise in inter-faith dialogue is why he chose the Darul Uloom at Deoband as his first stop. Having had the dubious pleasure of a day trip to that institution, I have said more than once that I have never seen a religious institution that has frightened me more. My troubles began at the gate when the bearded gatekeeper told me that the head maulana would never grant me an audience since I was not veiled. I responded that he could veil himself if he was that shy and gave myself a little unguided tour. I met rabid, young Islamists who refused to speak to me because they said they were forbidden to speak any language other than Arabic. In dress, manner and beard they affected what they thought was proper Arab culture. In the hour I spent wandering about among the fine buildings and manicured gardens of the Darul Uloom, I saw only one woman and she was so heavily veiled that all I saw of her were her eyes and the tip of her nose. It was as if I had strayed into a little patch of Saudi Arabia.

    ... contd.

    Next123
    Islam and India's Pre Islamic CultureBy: Anil Gupta | 14-Nov-2009 Reply | Forward Sir, Tavleen Singh is correct that by issuing fatwa against singing of Vandemataram the Deoband congregation was in fact rejecting everything India possesses of pre-Islamic period. In fact Vedas, Puranas, and the entire wisdom acquired by India in pre-Islamic period is inconsequential for the followers of Islam. Burning of entire libraries of Nalanda and Taxila universities for months bears an eloquent testimony to their barbaric actions.No doubt Islam as practiced in Hindustan peninsula is very different from that of west Asia. This was mentioned by late Zulfikar Ali Bhutto in his book from Pakistani jail "If I am Assasinated".But Indian Muslims have long been pampered by pseudo-secularists. This gives rise to a reaction amongst Hindus that they are being treated as second class citizen in their very own country.
    Muslim AppeasemenrtBy: Bala Varadarajan | 12-Nov-2009 Reply | Forward It is the strategy of the Congress Party to appease the Muslims at any cost. Indira Gandhi had made it into a fine art form. We had the spectacle of Congress Pary claiming to be secularist yet the coalition (at least in some states such as TN) included Muslim League. So we have this weird notion of Secularism - Muslim League is secular. In addition Muslims have the constitutional protectionto keeping their faith even when some of the tenets of the faith are totally abhorrent to International human rights instruments or even some of the fundamental rights enshrined in our constitution.
    You must not wear a red spectacle and complain that you are seeing red all around. By: Jatin | 11-Nov-2009 Reply | Forward Muslims were not native to India. Majority were converted Hindus who either the opportunists who wanted to get royal blessings or too coward to oppose forced conversion. That%u2019s a reality, whether Indian Muslims like it or not. You were the guest here and started demanding to rule the house the way you think right! If you broaden your definition of %u201Chouse%u201D and consider India as your home, then such divisive ideology does not allow you to live in peace and harmony with other members of the family. So long you harbor such fanatic idea; you are bound to have members like VHP or Shiv Sena in the same family. You must not wear a red spectacle and complain that you are seeing red all around.
    Tavleen Singh needs 'Enlightenment'By: Himadri Moharana | 10-Nov-2009 Reply | Forward Women, in India or elsewhere, deserve that dignity away from 'veils, locked indoors, illeteracy and helplessness'. Why does Tavleen wants to ensure that inflicting these indignities be restricted to Taliban or at the most to Saudi Arabia? And what's wrong if Home Minister talks about 'pluralism' to those people which Tavleen presumes have blocked ears (and minds). Does he need to talk to them in language and terms that pleases them? Can't we hope that good sense may prevail? Lets hope for the best!
    Destroy the fabric of the nationBy: Raghavendran Ramachandrarao | 10-Nov-2009 Reply | Forward Instead of promoting our national heroes, culture, value and traditions, Congress is busy destroying it. Congress by holding on to power for 60 odd years has weakened the nation systematically. Now we are sorrounded by external and internal threats and Congress is busy attending all meetings where anti - national resoultions are passed. Instead of getting out of that meeting where fatwa is passed against Vande mataram, he remained there sending a signal that it is ok for the nation. Congress won the recent elections massively and hence they are emboldened to do anything. People should defeat them and Elect BJP to save India.
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.