Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

The partyless wonders

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • It is certainly a great idea for professionals, entrepreneurs and activists to enter mainstream politics. But for that they have to first understand and respect politics and also to accept the heat and dust, the hard work, the take-no-prisoners competitive spirit that go with it. As the track record of the two prime ministerial aspirants (Manmohan Singh and Advani) shows you, politics surely has place for honest people. But it needs charisma, ambition, diligence, wisdom and experience of a very high order before you can make your mark, even save your deposit. Because people who come out and vote, defying the heat and cynicism, poverty, frustration, hunger and even the lure of a four-day weekend, understand what is good for them better than many of us in our ivory towers. Partisan politics sounds awful on 24-hour TV, but it keeps us together as a nation, giving different sections of our society, the minorities, Dalits, tribals, even the corporates and journalists a voice. If more than 90 per cent of distant Nagaland’s people come out to vote when less than half as many do in South Bombay it shows how parts of the country where real democracy was denied for long are so much more enthusiastic about it.

    Ads by Google

    Party politics is the most meritocratic profession of all in democracies. It is only politics that enables an Obama to defeat a Hillary Clinton for the leadership of the Democratic Party and its vote banks and then employ her as his secretary of state, or enables a Mayawati to build a party and rise from nowhere to give crores of Dalits a sense of participation and empowerment. Party politics does not prohibit the educated upper crust, but you cannot take it for granted and demand a lateral entry at the top by right, just because you are better educated or better “bred”. Most of our politicians have been at it for years, learning their ropes in college, panchayat or labour union politics. Most of them, as one look at the latest book published by this newspaper group (India’s Elected) would tell you, are also very well-educated, contrary to the Omkara stereotype. These new entrants will fail because they seem driven by a divine right to come and clean up our politics and governance, sullied for 60 years by illiterate, venal politicians and stupid voters. In a small way, they will remind you of the Swatantra Party of the erstwhile princes. They were swept away in no time by their own former subjects. And whether their governance of their feudal kingdoms was much better than our current candidates’ corporations is a question we shall overlook for the moment.

    ... contd.

    PreviousNext1234
    Couldn't agree moreBy: Anuranjan Roy | 17-May-2009 Reply | Forward I am in agreement with most of what Shekhar has put forward here except with the Mr. Advani being an honest politician bit. Being a politician is a full time job and it involves putting a lot of sweat and toil at the grass-roots level than most people would imagine. The reform has to come from within the major parties. Independent candidates running the show is sure to lead to chaos and anarchy. If all politicians (and let's add bureaucrats and policemen to the list, because as far as the urban hit-list goes they are up there with the politicians) were corrupt and beyond repair this nation would've gone to the dogs about 10 years into our Independence.
    Loksatta PartyBy: vk | 06-May-2009 Reply | Forward Loksatta is a political party now (not contested as an NGO) and it had fielded candidates in more than 250 constituencies (out of 294) in Andhra pradesh assembly elections. In the recent AP elections, the voter turnout was nearly 72.5% (I think it is second highest in state record). Voters are enthusiatic like never before and a lot of new voters have participated in this election which is a good sign for democracy in india. There are a good number of silent voters this time and Loksatta is expected to get a decent vote share(atleast 3-4%) in the current elections and strengthen their base in the future. Many People in the state are aware of the party and its agenda now through media. It doesn't seem like their survival/existence is a question now.
    LoksattaBy: vk | 06-May-2009 Reply | Forward Loksatta is a political party now (not contested as an NGO) and it had fielded candidates in more than 250 constituencies (out of 294) in Andhra pradesh assembly elections. In the recent AP elections, the voter turnout was nearly 72.5% (I think it is second highest in state record). Voters are enthusiatic like never before and a lot of new voters have participated in this election which is a good sign for democracy in india. There are a good number of silent voters this time and Loksatta is expected to get a decent vote share(atleast 3-4%) in the current elections and strengthen their base in the future. Many People in the state are aware of the party and It doesn't seem like their survival/existence is a question now.
    Honest Leader...?By: Aman | 06-May-2009 Reply | Forward Did you just call advani "honest people"...???
    A systematic assault on corruption, socialism, and communalism is startingBy: Sanjeev Sabhlok | 06-May-2009 Reply | Forward I totally support (in principle) what you've said, leaving aside minor details. Contesting elections as independents or a small party, and hoping to get elected and change things is like Don Quixote’s tilting at windmills. The Indian voter will shift allegiance from existing corrupt formations only when a major national party is available as an option at the hustings, with hundreds of outstanding leaders speaking from the same song sheet, communicating their message over the course of a few years.If our new breed politicians are serious they must unite into one or two major groups based on their policy preference, and work strategically and systematically over the next few years. Indeed, Shekhar, aware of such basic matters, a group (Freedom Team of India) has started about a year ago to work through this slower but surer option. I encourage you to drop by at http://freedomteam.in and provide us with your common sense and strategic thinking.
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.