Premium
This is an archive article published on April 13, 2009

Translate this

Among things that the Samajwadi Party officially opposes are fancy English education,computers,farm machinery,stock-trading,and shopping malls.

Among things that the Samajwadi Party officially opposes are fancy English education,computers,farm machinery,stock-trading,and shopping malls. If this stuff is seriously meant,it reveals the SP’s intellectual vacuity and disconnect with the outside world. If it is a text merely meant to rally the faithful (with no bearing on actual governance),it is shocking in its condescension to the people.

Mulayam Singh’s plan involves phasing out computers wherever human labour can be substituted — a plank that even the Left has left behind,because of its patent absurdity. Warming over a centuries-old man versus machine debate,the manifesto also pushes for some prelapsarian past where farmers would directly cultivate the land. India’s biggest global advantage has been its IT-competent,English-speaking population — a segment that more and more young people openly aspire to — and the SP’s manifesto essentially promises to send his imagined constituency spinning away from that orbit.

What’s more,it is unclear who the SP thought would be won over by this paranoia about English (Mulayam Singh Yadav’s own children,incidentally,have studied in English-speaking schools) — it is blindingly obvious that in India today,English is not merely a class marker; it is,more importantly,the language of global and equally national competitiveness. Dalit movements have long championed what was once reviled as Lord Macaulay’s imposition,as an uncomplicated language of advancement. Last year when Mayawati reversed the decade-long freeze on English,introducing it in primary schools,Uttar Pradesh education officials pointed out that four-fifths of electronic information is stored in English,and rejecting the language amounts to setting our faces against the networked world. Even though there are now more multilingual platforms (and machine translations) than before,the Web largely speaks English. Countries like China,which earlier resisted English,have now pragmatically shifted to conquering it for maximum advantage. It dominates international business,politics and culture more than any other language in human history. And as English has taken over the world,the world has also taken over and repurposed English — no tongue is as flexible,as it accommodates the idioms and accents of every locale it lives in. This is,perhaps,precisely the kind of agility and resourcefulness that the SP’s antiquated worldview cannot comprehend,or take on.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement