• Infighting within the BJP has severely damaged the image of the party, one wonders whether it is in fact hegemonic and regressive in practice. Looking at those who have walked out or been asked to leave it becomes evident that soon there may be intellectual bankruptcy within the party itself, surely Yashwant Sinha, Jaswant Singh, Sudheendra Kulkarni and Arun Shourie contributed to rigorous debate which is deemed healthy for any organisation. These changes usher in a sad moment for Indian democracy. Thus the question: can a democracy exist without a credible opposition?

— Rishibha Gupta

Delhi

Revive, reform

• The utter chaos, which is now prevalent in the BJP, is saddening to many, as it impinges upon the hopes and aspirations of a multi-party system that is crucial to a mature democracy. The BJP was once famous for its well-knit organisation, discipline, dedication and its rejection of dynastic politics. However, now it appears to resemble a party of despots desperate trying to stifle dissent. It’s time the BJP took stock of current criticism and ensured itself a future by proving it can serve as a credible opposition.

— V. Venkatasubramanian

Mumbai

Careful, SP

• It has been reported that the general secretary of the Samajwadi Party, Amar Singh, has invited expelled BJP stalwart Jaswant Singh to join his party. Whether or not this happens, or how far it progresses, Amar Singh needs to clarify or even better spell out his party’s stand on M.A. Jinnah as this seems to be the root of the current controversy.

... contd.