Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

US not negotiating Indo-Pak relations: Holbrooke

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • Holbrooke mullen
    Richard Holbrooke denied any attempts on his part to play negotiator between India and Pakistan.
    US underlines India's key role for success of Af-Pak policy

    New Delhi

    As it begins implementation of its new strategy on Afghanistan and Pakistan, the US on Wednesday underlined the critical role of India in the success of the policy as there was a "common threat".

    US Special Envoy Richard Holbrooke, who held talks with Foreign Secretary Shivshankar Menon and National Security Adviser M K Narayanan, underlined that he was not visiting the region to "negotiate" between India and Pakistan.

    "The answer is no," Holbrooke said at a press conference here when asked whether he had asked his Indian interlocutors to resume talks with Pakistan.

    "Let me just be clear on my one word answer. We did not come here to ask the Indians to do anything. We came here to inform about our trips (to Afghanistan and Pakistan) as we always do and to get their views. We did not come here with any requests," said Holbrooke, while addressing the press along with US Chairman of Joint Chiefs of Staff Admiral Mike Mullen.

    Ads by Google

    Holbrooke and Mullen emphasised that their visit here was in connection with the new strategy on Afghanistan and Pakistan, which the US has just started to implement.

    "We cannot settle issues like Afghanistan and many other issues without India's full involvement and its own expression of views," said Holbrooke while pointing out that he had come to "listen" to Indian views and that his discussions with Indian officials were "terrific".

    Contending that "priorities" of both India and the US in Afghanistan are the same, the Special Envoy on Afghanistan and Pakistan said "coordination", however, was missing and that his visit here along with Mullen was aimed at accelerating that.

    "Everyone in this part of the world should recognise that for the first time since Partition, India, Pakistan and the US face a common threat and a common challenge and we have a common task," he said.

    Acknowledging that there was "history" between India and Pakistan as well as between Pakistan and Afghanistan, he said "but now as we face a common threat, we must work together."

    He said the US is "working intensively with our friends in Pakistan to achieve a common goal. That is what we are doing. We know it's going to be difficult but the national security interests of all three countries are clearly at stake." Noting that Pakistan is at the centre of the common fight, Holbrooke said, "What happens in Afghanistan is profoundly affected by what happens in Pakistan and the two issues are deeply inter-related."

    He voiced concern over the peace deal between government and Taliban in Swat region of Pakistan and said the worries had been "further raised" after terror attacks on Sri Lankan cricket team and police training centre in Lahore.

    "What has happened in Swat has stunned many people in Pakistan," the Special Envoy said, adding "everyone in this part of the world should recognise what's happening."

    Holbrooke said during his visit to Pakistan he had met some people from Swat to "learn more" about the peace deal and observed that "it was a difficult and touching meeting".

    He described Baitullah Mehsud, chief of Pakistani Taliban as "a terrible man" and "a great danger to Pakistan, Afghanistan ... He (Mehsud) is as bad as any bad actor in a very dangerous region."

    Asked about his assessment on whether the ISI was ready to sever its ties with terrorists, Mullen said that one of the priority issues of his visits to Pakistan over the last one year has been the "focus on intelligence activities and doing that in a constructive way".

    He said the focus continues to be that but refused to go into the details of the discussions that were going on.

    Referring to his visit along with Mullen to Islamabad yesterday, Holbrooke said "we were not there, I repeat, not there to negotiate Pakistani-Indian relations ... I should make it clear."

    He said their stopover in New Delhi was to "inform and consult" the Indian government on the US strategy on Afghanistan and Pakistan.

    Mullen said the objective of the visit here was to "understand problems through your eyes" as the "leadership" of India is very critical. He said the US would seek to consult India in every engagement "to listen and learn".

    Emphasising that the new US strategy on Afghanistan involves joint military-civil effort, Holbrooke said Washington was keen to understand about India's "impressive" developmental activities in the trouble-torn nation.

    He hailed developmental activities being undertaken by India in Afghanistan which covers areas like road building, construction of Afghan Parliament and agriculture and said these run parallel to that of the US.

    He said further talks will be held between India and the US in this regard in the context of implementation of the new strategy on Afghanistan and Pakistan unveiled by President Barack Obama last month.

    Holbrooke said the previous US administrations of Bill Clinton and George W Bush had worked very hard in development and improvement of Indo-US relations which was bearing positive results.

    Those discussions focused on bilateral areas like trade, investment and nuclear issue, he said.

    "In entire process, we never really had sufficient talks with India on regional and global strategic issues and that was the missing factor. And that is what Admiral Mullen and I have come here to accelerate," he said.

    Mullen said India is a "vital leader" in the region and is playing a critical role in many positive ways. "We recognise that."

    The top US military official underlined that regional challenges of South Asia need regional solutions.

    "The challenges we have in Afghanistan, strategy in Afghanistan and Pakistan, military power alone is useless. It is civilian-military team that is so important, good governance along with security," he said.

    Will the Government Oblige?By: Swapan Chakravarthy | 09-Apr-2009 Reply | Forward Trust the Americans with their gimmicks and sooner or later you will find led into the garden path where compromise will be the word. This was the same with the 123-Agreement where we have given away a substantial negotiating advantage. And I am sure if we dipped into the Minutes of the Meeting, we are certain to find the overture to intervention in Kashmir all written on the wall. Will the Government oblige?
    Then Go to HellBy: Azad KAshmiri | 08-Apr-2009 Reply | Forward Then Go to Hell Halbroke.You Guys just let the region burning.No Indian Cares about Us Kashmiris people and Afraid of that we will spit on there faces if given right of self determination.Keep runing from reality you Hindus
    US not negotiating India, Pak relations: HolbrookeBy: Javed Khan | 08-Apr-2009 Reply | Forward Good Lad , Holbrooke. It is a good decision not to interfere in our Kashmir.It will be very good if you decide to stop all military aid to Pakistan Aid if any must be only civilian in nature. It will be the best decision that USA hasever made if America decides that the nuclear assets of Pakistan must be destroyed cpmpletly
    Holbrookes forced admissionBy: Hero Vaz | 08-Apr-2009 Reply | Forward Holbrooke has seen that India will not budge. That is why he has no alternative but to say that Indo-Pak relations are not being negotiated.
    HolbrookeBy: Gidwani | 08-Apr-2009 Reply | Forward Don't trust the Americans - they haven't made a wise foreign policy decision since the Marshall Plan after WW2. America's foreign policy tool is not wisdom but but its, now dwindling, military and economic power. They think they can bully all their adversaries into submission. This policy has been clearly known to have failed. India must rely on itself so solve its own problems but we will need better leadership than the cowardly people who are running the government at this time - its time to bring on Modi.
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.