Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

Was Partition inevitable? Desirable?

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • History is a great teacher. But it can also be a great tranquiliser. People, especially those societies that do not nurture a deep historical memory, tend to forget—indeed, want to forget—the tragic and bitter episodes in their collective life. As a result, new generations have only a faint knowledge and understanding of even cataclysmic events in the past that singed the lives of their fathers and forefathers. The natural going of painful happenings into oblivion may be regarded as welcome, if those happenings had no bearing on the present. After all, how can we at all live in peace if our conscious mind is filled with memories of all the wars, holocausts, genocides and injustices that took place in the past? But when events of the past, especially the recent past, have material bearing on a country’s present and its unfolding future, forgetting is not an option. It is a sure way to court more hardships. 

    The bloody partition of India is one such event that Indians, Hindus and Muslims both, cannot afford to forget. Not just because it was accompanied by the killing of close to a million people in a fratricidal bloodbath, the worst in India’s millennial history. Also, not only because Partition resulted in the largest ever cross-migration in the entire human history—Hindus and Sikhs uprooted from their homes in those territories that constituted Pakistan, and Muslims from UP, Bihar, Gujarat, Maharashtra and elsewhere in India migrating, some in duress and others voluntarily, to the newly created Muslim Nation.  Rather, we need to remember, examine, re-examine and learn from Partition history, principally because it has continued to determine the content and contours of the socio-political life of post-1947 India, also of the two other nations, Pakistan and Bangladesh, that were born out of undivided India. “The unexamined life,” says Socrates, “is not worth living.” He said it in the context of our individual lives.  However, in the context of a nation, the unexamined life is a prescription for inviting peril.  

    ... contd.

    Next1234
    Jinnah the secularistBy: Dinesh | 24-Aug-2009 Reply | Forward Sir, Jinnah was very secular - the only catch is that he was impatient for power- This is just like our Govt servants and politicians - they are very honest, the only catch is that they are impatient and want to get rich immediately - working hard to get rich is too slow a process for them.
    Partition of India....By: Prakash Kanungo | 24-Aug-2009 Reply | Forward After all come to think and "feel" about it...it was"Desirable thing" to have happened...All that Human Kachra is gone...just imagine if these Jihadies/ junkies were still be with us...and Ayyubs/yahyahs/ Bhuttos/Zias/Sharifs/ Musharrafs/ Kiyanies..would have been in Indian Army....My god...India would have gone to "stone Ages" by now....Even Mughals would have been ashamed...It is TIME..BJP and entire India accepts "Pakistan" as it exists and should be left alone...Just ignore this "jihadi Nation"...treat it like Rawanda or Peru...are we bothered about these nations on daily basis? Only trouble with Pakistan is that it is next door to us, having nautiating hate India Compulsions....Just ignore it... allow it to self destruct...and get along with India of 21st Century....Next generation wishes Pakistan well...and that it has no "historical Baggae" with it. Generation next would like to see a new BJP emerge and lease India from Congress culture of "Vote Bank Games."
    CongressBy: Vaid S C K | 24-Aug-2009 Reply | Forward Congress leaders have skillfully manged to distract attention of people on finding out real culprits responsible for serious crime against humanity by way of creating Two Nations. This has been possible for the reason that almost 4 decades after independence, congress ruled the country.But, in case, real and dispassionate analysis had been done, Nehru must have been held largely responsible for this.Gandhi's weakness for Nehru removed Subhash Chander Bose from the scene and other great leaders like Patel succumb to desires of Gandhi. Is it not strange or pathetic that Nehru agreed for partition resulting in killings of nearly one million people, followed by Kashmir- stopping Indian army to restore the territory to India, deal with China over Tibet creating life time trouble/insecurity for the nation and many more, still respecting and honouring Nehru dynasity? Can this happen in any other country?
    Not to forget the Islam's global agendaBy: S T | 23-Aug-2009 Reply | Forward May not be all, but there did exist and even today there exist many people whose religion happens to be islam, and they may be from any country such as Af-Pak, Iraq/Iran, Saudi etc. whose global dream is to convert as many lands into islamic as possible, India having been the target for centuries.The achievement of carving out of Pakistan as a purely a nation for muslims is a great success for them, and now they have no doubt been encouraged by it. With keeping issues like Kashmir alive, it is ensuring that this they do not lose sight of this dream.If there was no Shivaji, there would not have been a secular India possible today, because all of us infidels would have been either killed or converted by now.So while this stupid discussion on Jinnah may go on, we need another Shivaji to take on this current generation of Aurangzebs, which we were hoping would come from the likes of RSS/BJP. But alas, they do not seem to be getting it. When will we wake up?
    existential threatBy: S T | 24-Aug-2009 Reply | Forward All this debate over Jinnah will prove useful only if we come to the conclusion that, whoever was responsible for it , and whatever his good/bad qualities may have been, today we have a monster in the form of terrorist groups, funded and trained by ISI, Army, and hand in hand with polity and probably the entire nation of Paksitan, whose next aim will be nothing short of concurring all of India to make it Muslim country. May not be today, but surely over the next few centuries, if not decades. Now the question is, whether the RSS/BJP/Congress/Comnunists are going to realize and do anything about it?or Hindus will have to just hope and pray that some Shivaji will come to their rescue again sometime whenever God wills?
    please leave us aloneBy: muhammad Bilal | 23-Aug-2009 Reply | Forward pakistan is a reality and will remain forever. I think india should look to concentrate more on its own problems than telling us pakistanis what to do. india has half of its population under poverty , has more than dozen separatists movements spread all across india , has a huge muslim population that has to live like a 3rd class citizens. So india please do your on business and please forget this old nonsense of akhand baharat and finishing pakistan.
    May you live aloneBy: Prakash Kanungo | 29-Aug-2009 Reply | Forward History is a teacher,if you want to learn...What you got in last 60 yrs..all that it takes is one Jeep and Two armed personnel carrier to change Government.So we leave you alone for this,may you multiply and be fruitful...some day this One jeep will come with Jihadies and ruine you for "Good" and rest of the world will stop dealing with you in civilized manner.Jihadistan Paindabbad...Land of the "Pure" mubbarak ho...
    we cant leave you aloneBy: S T | 24-Aug-2009 Reply | Forward Pakistan is a reality today, but unless this reality is finished India can never rest in peace, in fact, India's own existence is in trouble because of existence of Pakistan which is founded on flawed 2 nation theory as well as Islam's incompatible viewpoint that only Islam is true religion, only Allah is one god and only 1 his messenger. All this is really stupid in the current context,but we have to live with it because we allowed this stupidity to grow to such an extent that those believers of these unacceptable ideas now even nuclear weapons. So Pakistan is a reality, but it needs to broken down so that it is not a reality any more.
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.