Sign In / Register
Make This My Home Page | Feedback |RSS
You are here: IE »   Story

Whatever the reasons, you can’t drop sitters at this level

  • Print
  • Mail This Article
  • Comments
  • Add to favorites
  • When we were growing up in Hyderabad, there were days when we got swarms of flying insects virtually enveloping a light. Somebody told us that if you placed a large flat vessel full of water under the light, the insects would fall into it. It worked. I suspect we are now seeing the equivalent of that old grandmother’s remedy here in South Africa because catches are going down faster than the insects did those days! It is inexplicable but now that it has become an epidemic, somebody has to find a reason and then, hopefully, a cure!

    You can understand batsmen struggling to come to terms with the bounce or the bowlers discovering that there is life beyond holding the ball seam up and hitting the deck hard in South Africa. But how does one explain catches going down? In T20 cricket we have now reached a stage where fielding standards are expected to be high; where really, an ordinary fielder rather than a brilliant one, should stand out. That hasn’t happened because the fielding has been pretty average and that is disappointing.

    Ads by Google

    Jonty Rhodes threw some light on it a few days ago when he talked about the difference between playing on the coast (Capetown, Port Elizabeth) and playing on the highlands (Johannesburg, Pretoria) or the highveld as they are called here. Because of the high altitude the ball travels further and so fielders might find the ball going a bit behind them as they wait for it. More interestingly, he said, the ball comes down much faster than you think it is going to and so you can be caught out of position. The obvious solution therefore is to practise a lot of skiers. Now while Jonty’s local knowledge, and his enormous skill, clears the air a bit, it still doesn’t explain why fielders are not catching more high balls in practice. Or maybe they are and it isn’t working. In fact, I remember a game in East London where the Chennai Super Kings had again dropped a few, catching practice had begun even as the presentation was going on.

    Another reason put forward is that with the onset of winter, the sun sets early and the twilight zone lingers for a while. That kind of light is brilliant for television cameramen giving you lovely images but not quite so for the fielders trying to sight a ball. Remember too that many grounds in South Africa are quite open, not tall concrete structures that block everything, and so the effect of the setting sun may get accentuated. I’d like to believe that is a factor but I would also like to believe that the huge coaching contingents that teams carry around these days would have evolved a solution by now. Unless of course it is, as multiple choice question papers often offer you as an option, ‘none of the above’ and that fielders are just not concentrating enough. Whatever the reason, it is not a great spectacle and you cannot have players at this level, being paid what they are, to falter in a crucial, but fundamental, aspect of cricket.

    Having said that I was hoping to see something new at the IPL and I now have. Last year Shaun Pollock introduced the loopy bouncer to T20 cricket. Hitherto, slower balls were fuller and only the likes of Venkatesh Prasad used to bowl it mid-pitch. Now Pollock was almost bowling a fast off break about halfway through and getting it to rise like a normal bouncer but only much slower. This year we have seen a thrilling variation on the old scoop shot played over fine leg. Most often that was played at about forty-five degrees or occasionally finer, maybe thirty degrees. Now twice in two days we have seen it played back over the wicketkeeper’s head (“back over the bowler’s head” used to be a favourite commentary line in the days gone by!!). It means of course that you move your own head out of line first and stop short of hitting the wicketkeeper on the helmet if he is standing up. Even more astonishingly, both Brendon McCullum and Tillakaratne Dilshan, managed to clear the boundary with it. It is thrilling to watch and just shows you how this game evolves with time, and with changing requirements.

    On another note I must confess to being a bit embarrassed at seeing the ages alongside the names of some of the players. Either there is an ageing pill that is taking effect too quickly, or we are seeing a major evolutionary change or people are just lying brazenly. I suspect we know the right answer and it is not “none of the above” this time. It must be stamped out now.

    Age of cricketersBy: J. Jayaraman | 16-May-2009 Reply | Forward Hope Harsh Bhogle must have watched age-category matches like under 22 etc. in India and must have noticed that a few players are definitely overaged, though "certificates" may prove otherwise. BCCI have ignored this factor for reasons best known to them. So this talk about "age" of player is nothing new.
    Not everything has an explanationBy: Jaideep Dave | 15-May-2009 Reply | Forward [i]Whatever the reasons, you can’t drop sitters at this level[/i]There doesn't have to be a reason for everything in life. Why are the fielders dropping catches? We don't know. Every catch is dropped for a different reason, sometimes due to misjudgment or due to ball not being visible due to the crowd-backdrop or some other reason. Or maybe it is 'it just is', reasonless phenomena.And I agree about the commentary thingie. It's been horrendous. Let's not blame Harsha. He cannot shit in the plate from which he eats. The blame falls squarely on SEX max and organizers like Modi, that they allow such exemplary stupidity (you know who i am referring to) to be on air. Inexcusable!
    On the subject of age..By: Alok | 15-May-2009 Reply | Forward ...given that there is a specific age-group prize in this tournament, I wonder if Messrs Modi
    RE: How about some introspection on the IPL television coverage...By: Sanjay | 15-May-2009 Reply | Forward Couldn’t agree more with Sudheer. While one is commenting on cricketers and their ages, why not some introspection of commentary team of which the author of this article is a member!!! What next are they going to sell???
    How about some introspection on the IPL television coverage...By: Sudheer Ravindra | 15-May-2009 Reply | Forward Nice points about the standard of catching and the issue about age. Now, we would appreciate some candid comments about the pandering by the commentary team! What the heck is a 'DLF maximum' or a 'Citi moment of success'(now that is a company that you associate with success!)? May be it is too close to home to comment on. It is absolutely unbelievable the way you guys have sold out!
    Post a Comment
    Name:
    Email:
    Title:
    Maximum characters allowed     
    Comment:
    TERMS OF USE:
    The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
    I agree to the terms of use.