Screen: The business of entertainment  
 
  The Indian Express
 
 
 
   PUBLICATIONS
 
  Expressindia
  The Indian Express
  The Financial Express
  Screen
  City Newslines
  Kashmir Live
  Loksatta
  Express Computer
 COMMUNITY
 
  Message Board
 SUBSCRIPTIONS
 
  Free Newsletter
  Express North
American Edition
  IE ARCHIVE
    Search by Date
 
  COLUMNISTS

July 14, 2001
Talk Back

Go Mr Sinha: We’ll trust you more!

I have come to the conclusion that we are an insensitive country: whenever anyone makes a mistake we think he should be punished. We believe that criminals should go to jail; murderers should be hung and those who cheat us should be locked up. How unfair this is. Now look at the song and dance we’re making about Yashwant Sinha. Everyone’s baying for his blood: they want him to step down and he like all good Indians is very puzzled. His track record has been impeccable: He has ensured that the country’s tax payer funds every silly mistake he and his ministry make: so I am not surprised if now we, the taxpayers, will have to fund his UTI debacle. But why blame Sinha. Like all ministers of this Government, he too can claim to be ignorant: in fact the manner in which the ministers claim their ignorance on everything makes me wonder if this country is running on auto-pilot.

Look at the innocence of Sinha: when questioned as to whether that devious UTI Chairman consulted him, all he said was no. He then went to add that the Ministry was kept in the dark. If this is how your ministry works Mr Sinha, then go and borrow lanterns from Laloo’s Bihar. My worry is not just the UTI but instead some other corporations that you ultimately rule over. But then I agree with you: you as the Finance Minister have been so much in the dark that our economy is today in a tailspin inspite of your unbridled optimism. You have ensured that millions of Indians lose, overnight, their investments because you and your stooges believed in a man who was, I have been told, intrinsically corrupt. The FM has shown a complete lack of accountability and has opened himself and his Prime Minister to the kind of Parliamentary ridicule which will be certainly unmatched. I cannot understand how Yashwant Sinha could even make a comment which suggests HE DID NOT KNOW.

It is your business to know, Mr Sinha and if for some reason you have not been informed, then heads need to roll. You should fire some of your bureaucrats as you should certainly offer to resign. I am aware that for you, this Ministry holds some significance but look at the bloomers that your Ministry has unleashed. It is no secret, Mr Sinha, that people hold you singularly responsible: it may suit you to ignore this or you may, like all crafty politicians, say this is a conspiracy to oust you: let me tell you the plain truth: you need to resign for what you have done to the Indian public. I do not believe anyone in the investing public believes you any more. Just look at Ketan Parekh; look at the role that SEBI played; it is sad that you continue to occupy this high office and nothing seems to move you out. Forget confidence building measures with Musharraf’s Pakistan: first build them in India.

What angers me is also that people in this country can do so much damage and get away so lightly. The UTI Chairman should be locked up: he has destroyed the common man’s faith in his Government. This Government should be investigating all those companies which withdrew their investments in UTI within a span of one month: they knew something which the common man did not: there is no doubt that they were forewarned by a head of that corporation who gave away money as if it belonged to him. Mr Sinha, you need to realise that you are holding this office in trust: it is not your jagir and never will be. At the same time, your people down the line must realise that when organisations like UTI mess up, people’s lives are destroyed: but why should you and your johnnies care. Your money was not involved.

There are several steps that Vajpayee needs to take: Mr Prime Minister, you need to ask your Finance Minister to go and he must take the Subramanyams of this world: it is officers like Subramanyam who must be made examples of — you need to be seen punishing corrupt and self-serving heads of institutions: these very officials become satraps in their own right since in many cases they handout largesse to ministers and their relatives if not to an ever-obliging media which then again immunises them from criticism because there is a clear violation of all governance — Your Government has spent more in investigating the corrupt rather than doing what you it is supposed to: book them and ensure processes and systems fall in place to avoid any recurrences: it is obvious your erudite Finance Minister has not learnt from the mistakes of the past.
The time for heads to roll has come. I admire Yashwant Sinha for his statement that the buck stops with him: now if he can rid himself of doublespeak, he should just step down or better still, step aside. And to be fair to him, he must take the Finance Secretary with him.

This country can hardly afford an ill-informed Finance Minister. For that matter, neither can your Cabinet, Mr Prime Minister!

 

Earlier Columns

Write to the Editor
Mail this story
Print this story