If
Basu went West, Buddha heads East
SUBRATA
NAGCHOUDHURY
KOLKATA,
SEPTEMBER 18: FOREIGN trips to woo investments had become
an annual feature of former Chief Minister Jyoti Basu’s 24-year
rule in Bengal. Following in his footsteps, his successor
Buddhadeb Bhattacharya set out on Sunday on his maiden foreign
tour to Japan on a week-long visit to look for foreign investments.
But,
while Basu always headed towards the West, Buddhadeb has chosen
his destination in the East — Japan. His decision to visit
Japan appears to be a conscious, calculated one. He is careful
not to invite the same criticism Basu had invited after his
successive visits but with largely unsuccessful outcome to
the UK and the USA.
Basu’s foreign trips in search of investment had become something
of a joke among political opponents who branded them as ‘‘pleasure
trips’’. They said Basu’s trips, totalling not less than a
score, were given an official status simply to cover the expenses.
During Basu’s tenure, the WBIDC chairman and CPI(M) MP, Somnath
Chatterjee, was accused of the same ‘‘game’’ of taking big
industry teams overseas without any perceptible benefits.
In
the last Assembly session, for example, in a written answer
to a question posed by an Opposition member, the state Commerce
and Industries Minister said that the WBIDC chairman had undertaken
six foreign trips in the past five years at a cost of Rs 22.28
lakh to the exchequer. And to a supplementary regarding the
total investment raised out of these trips, the government
dodged a straight answer and instead noted: ‘‘The purpose
of these trips was to promote the state among foreign investors
and to build a positive image of West Bengal for attracting
foreign collaborators.’’
Buddhadeb,
in contrast, is on safe ground. The Japanese record of investments
in West Bengal is fairly impressive. In the past decade, the
state has witnessed Japanese investments in the following
areas:
- A
Japanese loan of over Rs 1,200 crore for the Bakreswar thermal
power plant.
- Mitsubishi
Chemical Corporation (MCC), a Fortune 500 company, has set
up a plant to make 3,50,000 tonne a year of purified terephthalic
acid (PTA) at Haldia with an investment of Rs 1,600 crore.
- Over
Rs 400 crore financial assistance through Japan Bank for
International Cooperation (JBIC) to improve the road infrastructure
in Kolkata by building a series of critical
flyovers.
Having
analysed the nature of investments, industry circles in Kolkata
say that the Japanese investment in the PTA project in Haldia
was aimed at tapping a huge market in North-East India, Bangladesh
and other neighbouring countries. PTA is an intermediary for
synthetic fibres and has a huge untapped market. There is
no denying the fact that Kolkata happens to be a big market
and is also a potentially viable hub for exploiting the region’s
market.
The
other two substantial investments — in power and road infrastructure
sector — are said to be dictated by Japan’s own internal economic
compulsions. These investments are avenues for engaging associate
Japanese companies and personnel. The sources point out that
in the Bakreswar project, for example, Bhel and Itochu were
engaged as project consultants. Similarly, in the road infrastructure
flyover project, Yachio Corporation is engaged as a consultant.
In
fact, it would not be surprising if the Japanese decide to
come in a bigger way in infrastructure development, which,
according to the new Left Front government, is one of the
priority thrust areas.
Buddhadeb’s observations, according to party sources, are
also significant. The party mouthpiece Ganashakti quoted Buddhadeb
as saying that: ‘‘With the Japanese undergoing an economic
slump, this is probably the best time to woo investments from
them.’’ From today, Buddhadeb will talk with Mitsubishi, Electric
Power Development Corporation, Marubeni, Suzuki, and some
others. He will also interact with the Indo-Japan Business
Cooperation, Japan Federation of Economic Organisations, and
officials from Japanese Industry and Commerce Ministry.
‘‘With
reasonable Japanese presence in Bengal, Buddhadeb is on a
win-win situation,’’ said a party colleague. But he is certainly
on a sticky pitch for his comments before departure. When
asked why he was taking such a small team to Japan (he is
accompanied only by his secretary A.K. Deb, CII representative
Tarun Das and will be joined by R.P. Goenka) in sharp contrast
to bigger visits earlier, Buddhadeb said: ‘‘It’s simply because
I am going on business.’’
|